Kilroy D A
Emergency Department, Trafford General Hospital, Manchester M41 5SL, UK.
Emerg Med J. 2004 Jul;21(4):411-3. doi: 10.1136/emj.2003.012435.
Problem based learning (PBL) has been the subject of considerable interest and debate in medical undergraduate and, increasingly, postgraduate education in recent years. Its supporters maintain that PBL enhances learning by providing a highly motivational environment for acquisition of knowledge, which is well received by those who take part in it. Critics argue that PBL is a time consuming exercise, often undertaken by people with a limited appreciation of its complexities, and the lack of evidence that PBL translates into better clinical competence brings into question the relevance of such intensive learning methods in everyday practice. This article outlines the background to PBL, explains its mechanics in action, and considers the potential disadvantages of its use as a clinical learning tool in the emergency department.
基于问题的学习(PBL)近年来一直是医学本科教育以及越来越多的研究生教育中备受关注和争议的主题。其支持者认为,PBL通过提供一个高度激励性的知识获取环境来促进学习,这受到了参与其中的人的好评。批评者则认为,PBL是一项耗时的活动,通常由那些对其复杂性认识有限的人进行,而且缺乏证据表明PBL能转化为更好的临床能力,这使得这种强化学习方法在日常实践中的相关性受到质疑。本文概述了PBL的背景,解释了其实际操作机制,并探讨了在急诊科将其用作临床学习工具的潜在弊端。