Henna Márcia Riromi, Del Nero Rozemeire G M, Sampaio Cristina Zugaiar S, Atallah Alvaro Nagib, Schettini Sérgio Tomaz, Castro Aldemar Araújo, Soares Bernardo Garcia de Oliveira
Pediatr Surg Int. 2004 May;20(5):357-9. doi: 10.1007/s00383-004-1198-3. Epub 2004 Jun 24.
The importance of cryptorchidism treatment concerns the possibility of diminishing risk of malignant degeneration and improving fertility. Success rates of hormonal treatment vary: 0-55% with human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) and 9-78% with gonadotropin-releasing hormone (GnRH). Due to uncertainties regarding the effectiveness of this treatment, a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) on hormonal cryptorchidism treatment was done using the methodology of Cochrane Collaboration. Two studies compared hCG with GnRH, with a testicular descent rate of 25% vs. 18%, respectively. Nine trials compared intranasal LHRH with placebo, with complete testicular descent rates of 19% vs. 5%. Two other studies comparing doses and administration intervals could not be pooled together due to heterogeneity. With the information analyzed until the present, the evidence for the use of hCG vs. GnRH shows advantages for hCG, and this review also shows that there is evidence that luteinizing hormone releasing hormone (LHRH) is more effective than placebo. But because this evidence is based on few trials, with small sample sizes and moderated risk of bias, this treatment cannot be recommended for everyone, and there is no evidence that supports hCG's use in larger doses and larger intervals. Results from this systematic review are important for developing better RCTs that may decrease the uncertainty of cryptorchidism treatment.
隐睾症治疗的重要性在于降低恶性病变风险和改善生育能力的可能性。激素治疗的成功率各不相同:人绒毛膜促性腺激素(hCG)治疗的成功率为0 - 55%,促性腺激素释放激素(GnRH)治疗的成功率为9 - 78%。由于这种治疗效果存在不确定性,因此采用Cochrane协作网的方法对激素治疗隐睾症的随机对照试验(RCT)进行了系统评价和荟萃分析。两项研究比较了hCG与GnRH,睾丸下降率分别为25%和18%。九项试验比较了鼻内促黄体生成素释放激素(LHRH)与安慰剂,完全睾丸下降率分别为19%和5%。另外两项比较剂量和给药间隔的研究因异质性无法合并。根据目前分析的信息,使用hCG与GnRH的证据显示hCG具有优势,本评价还表明有证据表明促黄体生成素释放激素(LHRH)比安慰剂更有效。但由于该证据基于少数试验,样本量小且偏倚风险中等,因此不能向所有人推荐这种治疗方法,也没有证据支持大剂量、长间隔使用hCG。该系统评价的结果对于开展更好的RCT很重要,这可能会降低隐睾症治疗的不确定性。