Armfield Jason M, Spencer A John
Dental School, Faculty of Health Sciences, The University of Adelaide, Adelaide, SA, Australia.
Community Dent Oral Epidemiol. 2004 Aug;32(4):283-96. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0528.2004.00167.x.
There are concerns that the consumption of unfluoridated bottled and tank water may put children at increased risk of developing caries.
The aim of this study was to investigate the relationship between nonpublic water consumption (either from bottles or rainwater tanks) and socioeconomic status (SES) and both deciduous and permanent caries experience.
A random sample of children enrolled in the School Dental Service of South Australia participated in the study (response rate = 71.8%, n = 9988).
Forty-five per cent of children had greater than 50% lifetime consumption of nonpublic water while 36% of children had 0% lifetime consumption. Increased use of nonpublic water occurred for children from lower socioeconomic groups, two-parent families and children from nonmetropolitan areas, with these results most likely a result of the residential location of the children. Multivariate modelling revealed a significant positive relationship between deciduous caries experience and consumption of nonpublic water, even after controlling for the age and sex of the child, SES and residential location. This relationship was significant only for those children with 100% lifetime availability of fluoridated water. The effect of consumption of nonpublic water on permanent caries experience was not significant. It is postulated that these findings may result from the lower caries activity in the permanent dentition of children aged 10-15 and possible dietary confounders.
Recommendations are made for the addition of fluoride to bottled water, especially with regard to the oral health of younger children.
人们担心饮用未加氟的瓶装水和水箱水可能会增加儿童患龋齿的风险。
本研究旨在调查非公共供水(瓶装水或雨水箱水)的饮用与社会经济地位(SES)以及乳牙和恒牙龋齿经历之间的关系。
南澳大利亚州学校牙科服务机构登记的儿童随机样本参与了本研究(应答率 = 71.8%,n = 9988)。
45%的儿童一生中超过50%的饮水量是非公共供水,而36%的儿童一生中非公共供水的饮水量为0%。社会经济地位较低的群体、双亲家庭以及来自非大城市地区的儿童使用非公共供水的比例增加,这些结果很可能是儿童居住地点所致。多变量建模显示,即使在控制了儿童的年龄、性别、社会经济地位和居住地点之后,乳牙龋齿经历与非公共供水的饮用之间仍存在显著的正相关关系。这种关系仅在那些一生中100%可获得加氟水的儿童中显著。非公共供水的饮用对恒牙龋齿经历的影响不显著。据推测,这些发现可能是由于10 - 15岁儿童恒牙的龋齿活动较低以及可能存在的饮食混杂因素所致。
建议在瓶装水中添加氟化物,尤其是考虑到年幼儿童的口腔健康。