Maiburg Bas H J, Rethans Jan-Joost E, van Ree Jan W
Department of General Practice, Maastricht University, Maastricht, The Netherlands.
Fam Pract. 2004 Aug;21(4):425-8. doi: 10.1093/fampra/cmh413.
Published guidelines and lists of topics in nutrition education for GPs are affected by practical drawbacks, which prevent them from being easily implemented in vocational training curricula.
Our aim was to draw up a concise priority list of disease-related nutrition topics reflecting the needs among Dutch GPs for nutrition education geared to everyday practice, which can be used to decide on the main topics and educational content of computer-based instruction.
This was a two-round Delphi study, using pilot-tested questionnaires carried out among 41 GPs who attended a national CME meeting on nutrition in The Netherlands. Sum scores of, and summarized comments on nutrition topics and their frequencies in top-10 lists drawn up by respondents were the main outcome measures.
The response in both Delphi rounds was high (93 and 95%). Analysis of questionnaires in both rounds yielded a priority list of disease-related nutrition topics, with the 14 highest ranking topics identical in both rounds. A fifteenth topic, only found in the second questionnaire, completed the priority list. A group of experts assessed this list as fully acceptable.
It was possible to compile a priority list of disease-related nutrition topics reflecting the needs of GPs for nutrition education. Based on the results of the Delphi study, we generated the following list of five priority topics: weight problems; diabetes mellitus; hypercholesterolaemia; intestinal complaints; and hypertension. This list of five and the summarized comments of respondents will determine the main topics and educational content of a computer-based instruction we are currently developing.
已发布的全科医生营养教育指南和主题清单存在实际缺陷,这使得它们难以在职业培训课程中轻松实施。
我们的目标是制定一份简洁的疾病相关营养主题优先清单,反映荷兰全科医生对适合日常实践的营养教育的需求,该清单可用于确定基于计算机教学的主要主题和教育内容。
这是一项两轮德尔菲研究,使用在荷兰参加全国营养继续医学教育会议的41名全科医生中进行预测试的问卷。主要结果指标是受访者列出的营养主题的总分、总结评论及其在十大清单中的出现频率。
两轮德尔菲研究的回复率都很高(分别为93%和95%)。对两轮问卷的分析产生了一份疾病相关营养主题的优先清单,两轮中排名最高的14个主题相同。在第二轮问卷中才出现的第15个主题完成了优先清单。一组专家评估该清单完全可以接受。
有可能编制一份反映全科医生营养教育需求的疾病相关营养主题优先清单。根据德尔菲研究的结果,我们生成了以下五个优先主题清单:体重问题;糖尿病;高胆固醇血症;肠道疾病;和高血压。这五个主题清单以及受访者的总结评论将决定我们目前正在开发的基于计算机教学的主要主题和教育内容。