Asghari Fariba, Samadi Aniseh, Rashidian Arash
Associate Professor, Medical Ethics and History of Medicine Research Center, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran;
Researcher, Medical Ethics and History of Medicine Research Center, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran;
J Med Ethics Hist Med. 2013 Aug 5;6:7. eCollection 2013.
Education needs assessment is one of the essential components of curriculum development. In this study, we aimed to assess the educational needs of general physicians for medical ethics. We conducted a three-stage Delphi study of general physicians' views on important ethical issues in their practice. In the item generation stage we retrieved 45 important educational items from a survey of general physicians, patients, well known ethical clinicians, and a review of other universities' curricula and international literature. The questionnaire was designed to ask the importance of each generated item. We then sent the questionnaire to general physicians. Items scored as highly important by more than 80% of the respondents in the first or second consensus development surveys were considered as educational priorities. Four academic medical ethics teachers reviewed and commented on the findings. The response rate to the first consensus development survey was 38%, of whom 77% also responded to the second survey. We developed consensus on 24 medical ethics items for inclusion in medical ethics curriculum. All items were also considered important by medical ethics teachers, and they added four further items to the list. Despite the attention given to ethical issues originating from technological advances, the most important educational needs of general physicians in medical ethics are still the traditional issues concerning the doctor-patient relationship and professionalism.
教育需求评估是课程开发的重要组成部分之一。在本研究中,我们旨在评估全科医生对医学伦理学的教育需求。我们针对全科医生对其临床实践中重要伦理问题的看法开展了一项三阶段德尔菲研究。在条目生成阶段,我们通过对全科医生、患者、知名伦理临床医生进行调查,并查阅其他大学课程及国际文献,获取了45个重要教育条目。问卷旨在询问每个生成条目的重要性。然后我们将问卷发送给全科医生。在第一轮或第二轮共识发展调查中,超过80%的受访者将其评为高度重要的条目被视为教育重点。四位医学伦理学教师对研究结果进行了审查并发表了评论。第一轮共识发展调查的回复率为38%,其中77%的人也回复了第二轮调查。我们就纳入医学伦理学课程的24个医学伦理学条目达成了共识。医学伦理学教师也认为所有条目都很重要,并在清单中又增加了四个条目。尽管人们关注技术进步引发的伦理问题,但全科医生在医学伦理学方面最重要的教育需求仍然是与医患关系和职业精神相关的传统问题。