Schroeder Emily B, Whitsel Eric A, Evans Gregory W, Prineas Ronald J, Chambless Lloyd E, Heiss Gerardo
Duke University School of Medicine, Durham, NC, USA.
J Electrocardiol. 2004 Jul;37(3):163-72. doi: 10.1016/j.jelectrocard.2004.04.004.
Due to the sparse data on the repeatability of short and ultra-short term heart rate variability (HRV) measures, we measured the repeatability of common HRV measures derived from 10-second, 2-minute, and 6-minute recordings in 63 healthy men and women, aged 45-64, in Chapel Hill, North Carolina. Three 10-second and 2 six-minute heart rate recordings were obtained during each of 2 visits, separated by 1 to 2 weeks. We partitioned the measurement error into components and computed intraclass correlation coefficients using nested, random effects models. Repeatability improved with the length of recording: intraclass correlation coefficients were greater than 0.7 for 6-minute measures and 2-minute time domain measures and greater than 0.5 for 2-minute frequency domain measures. Repeatability of measures from 10-second records was lower, but improved considerably when the mean from 2 or 3 records was used. Correlations between the same measures from different length recordings were quite high. Our findings support the use of records of at least 5 minutes in length in epidemiological studies, in accordance with previous guidelines. Researchers using 10-second records should consider taking the mean of several recordings, when possible, or using statistical methods to correct for measurement error.
由于关于短期和超短期心率变异性(HRV)测量重复性的稀疏数据,我们在北卡罗来纳州教堂山对63名年龄在45 - 64岁的健康男性和女性进行了研究,测量了从10秒、2分钟和6分钟记录中得出的常见HRV测量指标的重复性。在两次就诊期间,每次获取3次10秒和2次6分钟的心率记录,就诊间隔为1至2周。我们将测量误差分解为各个成分,并使用嵌套随机效应模型计算组内相关系数。重复性随着记录长度的增加而提高:对于6分钟测量指标和2分钟时域测量指标,组内相关系数大于0.7,对于2分钟频域测量指标,组内相关系数大于0.5。10秒记录测量指标的重复性较低,但当使用2次或3次记录的平均值时,重复性有显著提高。不同长度记录中相同测量指标之间的相关性相当高。我们的研究结果支持根据先前的指南,在流行病学研究中使用至少5分钟时长的记录。使用10秒记录的研究人员应尽可能考虑采用多次记录的平均值,或使用统计方法校正测量误差。