Tarkiainen Tuula H, Timonen Kirsi L, Tiittanen Pekka, Hartikainen Juha E K, Pekkanen Juha, Hoek Gerard, Ibald-Mulli Angela, Vanninen Esko J
Dept. of Clinical Physiology and Nuclear Medicine, Kuopio University Hospital and University of Kuopio, Finland.
Clin Auton Res. 2005 Dec;15(6):394-9. doi: 10.1007/s10286-005-0302-7.
Heart rate variability (HRV) is a widely used method to assess cardiac autonomic control. However, the reproducibility of especially short-term HRV has not been properly evaluated. Therefore, we assessed the stability of short-term HRV over a three to four month period. We had seven consecutive electrocardiographic (ECG) recordings from 89 subjects with stable coronary artery disease obtained during a large multicenter study. The HRV assessments were performed from these 40-minute ECG-recordings simulating normal daily activities, i. e., recordings consisting of 5 to 10 minute periods of rest, paced breathing, standing, submaximal exercise and recovery. Both time and frequency domain HRV analyses were conducted from the whole 40-minute recordings and from the 5-minute periods of rest and paced breathing. The coefficient of variation (CV) varied between 5.1-16.7% for the 40-minute and 6.0-37.1% for the 5-minute time domain and 4.4-11.0 % for the 40-minute and 7.2-16.5 % for the 5-minute frequency domain measurements. The mean of the RR intervals and the total power showed the highest stability over time. The most unstable measure was the standard deviation of all NN intervals (SDNN). In conclusion, most short-term HRV measures were highly stable over time indicating low physiological variation. However, the SDNN showed large variability in consecutive recordings.
心率变异性(HRV)是一种广泛用于评估心脏自主神经控制的方法。然而,尤其是短期HRV的可重复性尚未得到恰当评估。因此,我们评估了短期HRV在三到四个月期间的稳定性。我们从一项大型多中心研究中获取了89例稳定型冠状动脉疾病患者连续七次的心电图(ECG)记录。HRV评估是根据这些模拟正常日常活动的40分钟ECG记录进行的,即由5至10分钟的休息、定频呼吸、站立、次极量运动及恢复阶段组成的记录。对整个40分钟记录以及休息和定频呼吸的5分钟阶段均进行了时域和频域HRV分析。40分钟时域测量的变异系数(CV)在5.1 - 16.7%之间,5分钟时域测量的CV在6.0 - 37.1%之间;40分钟频域测量的CV在4.4 - 11.0%之间,5分钟频域测量的CV在7.2 - 16.5%之间。RR间期均值和总功率随时间显示出最高的稳定性。最不稳定的测量指标是所有NN间期的标准差(SDNN)。总之,大多数短期HRV测量指标随时间高度稳定,表明生理变异较低。然而,SDNN在连续记录中显示出较大变异性。