Naylor Carlie-Jane, Griffiths Rhonda D, Fernandez Ritin S
Centre for Applied Nursing Research, South Western Sydney Area Health Service, Sydney, Australia.
JPEN J Parenter Enteral Nutr. 2004 Jul-Aug;28(4):251-8. doi: 10.1177/0148607104028004251.
Total parenteral nutrition (TPN) is a specialized form of nutrition support. The complexity associated with the management of patients receiving TPN therapy has led to the development of multidisciplinary TPN teams. The purpose of this review was to critically analyze the literature and present the best available evidence that investigated the effectiveness of multidisciplinary TPN teams in the provision of TPN to adult hospitalized patients.
A systematic review of studies identified from the Cochrane Library (2001, Issue 4), CINAHL, Complete MEDLINE, Complete Biomedical Collection, Complete Nursing Collection, and EMBASE, published in any language.
Eleven studies, 4 with concurrent controls and 7 with historical controls, were eligible for inclusion in the review. Results of the studies indicate that the incidence of total mechanical complications is reduced in patients managed by the TPN team. However, the benefit of the TPN team in the reduction of catheter-related sepsis remains inconclusive. Four of the 5 studies reported fewer total metabolic and electrolyte abnormalities in patients cared for by the team, and these patients were more likely to receive their optimal caloric intake. However it was unclear if the management of the patients by the TPN team prevented the inappropriate use of TPN therapy. Although only 2 studies (n = 356) investigated total costs associated with management of patients by the TPN teams, there was evidence that a team approach is a cost-effective strategy.
Overall, the general effectiveness of the TPN team has not been conclusively demonstrated. There is evidence that patients managed by TPN teams have a reduced incidence of total mechanical complications; however, it is unclear if there is a reduction in catheter-related sepsis and metabolic and electrolyte complications. The available evidence, although limited, suggests financial benefits from the introduction of multidisciplinary TPN teams in the hospital setting.
全胃肠外营养(TPN)是一种特殊形式的营养支持。与接受TPN治疗患者管理相关的复杂性促使了多学科TPN团队的发展。本综述的目的是批判性地分析文献,并呈现关于多学科TPN团队为成年住院患者提供TPN有效性的最佳现有证据。
对从Cochrane图书馆(2001年第4期)、CINAHL、完整MEDLINE、完整生物医学文集、完整护理文集和EMBASE中检索到的研究进行系统综述,不限语言发表年份。
11项研究符合纳入综述标准,其中4项有同期对照,7项有历史对照。研究结果表明,由TPN团队管理的患者总机械并发症发生率降低。然而,TPN团队在降低导管相关败血症方面的益处仍不明确。5项研究中的4项报告称,由该团队护理的患者总代谢和电解质异常较少,且这些患者更有可能获得最佳热量摄入。然而,尚不清楚TPN团队对患者的管理是否能防止TPN治疗的不当使用。尽管仅有2项研究(n = 356)调查了TPN团队管理患者的总成本,但有证据表明团队方法是一种具有成本效益的策略。
总体而言,TPN团队的总体有效性尚未得到确凿证明。有证据表明,由TPN团队管理的患者总机械并发症发生率降低;然而,导管相关败血症以及代谢和电解质并发症是否减少尚不清楚。现有证据虽然有限,但表明在医院环境中引入多学科TPN团队有经济益处。