Subrungruang Ittisak, Mungthin Mathirut, Chavalitshewinkoon-Petmitr Porntip, Rangsin Ram, Naaglor Tawee, Leelayoova Saovanee
Department of Protozoology, Faculty of Tropical Medicine, Mahidol, University, Bangkok, Thailand.
J Clin Microbiol. 2004 Aug;42(8):3490-4. doi: 10.1128/JCM.42.8.3490-3494.2004.
An evaluation of the sensitivities of three DNA extraction methods, i.e., FTA filter paper, a QIAamp stool mini kit, and a conventional phenol-chloroform method, by using specimens with known concentrations of Enterocytozoon bieneusi spores was performed. FTA filter paper and the QIAamp stool mini kit were the most sensitive methods, which could detect E. bieneusi in specimens with a concentration of 800 spores/ml. We also compared five previously described PCR methods that use five different primer pairs for the detection of E. bieneusi and showed that MSP3-MSP4B and EBIEF1-EBIER1 were the most sensitive primers. Although both sets of primers showed the same sensitivity, using the MSP3-MSP4B primers can directly provide genotypic information by sequencing. A blinded diagnostic test to compare PCR and light microscopy methods for the detection of E. bieneusi in stool specimens was also conducted. The use of FTA filter paper for DNA extraction together with the PCR method using the primer pair MSP3-MSP4B showed 100% sensitivity and 100% specificity for the detection of E. bieneusi in stool specimens, while the light microscopy method gave a sensitivity of 86.7% and a specificity of 100%.
通过使用已知浓度的微小隐孢子虫孢子标本,对三种DNA提取方法,即FTA滤纸片法、QIAamp粪便迷你试剂盒法和传统苯酚-氯仿法的敏感性进行了评估。FTA滤纸片法和QIAamp粪便迷你试剂盒法是最敏感的方法,能够检测到浓度为800个孢子/毫升标本中的微小隐孢子虫。我们还比较了五种先前描述的用于检测微小隐孢子虫的PCR方法,这些方法使用了五对不同的引物,结果表明MSP3-MSP4B和EBIEF1-EBIER1是最敏感的引物。尽管两组引物显示出相同的敏感性,但使用MSP3-MSP4B引物可通过测序直接提供基因型信息。还进行了一项盲法诊断试验,以比较PCR和光学显微镜方法检测粪便标本中微小隐孢子虫的情况。使用FTA滤纸片法提取DNA并结合使用引物对MSP3-MSP4B的PCR方法,对粪便标本中微小隐孢子虫的检测显示出100%的敏感性和100%的特异性,而光学显微镜方法的敏感性为86.7%,特异性为100%。