医生与补充替代医学:夏威夷的培训、态度及实践
Physicians and complementary-alternative medicine: training, attitudes, and practices in Hawaii.
作者信息
Chan Pon-Sang, Wong Michelle M
出版信息
Hawaii Med J. 2004 Jun;63(6):176-81.
INTRODUCTION
There were only few studies addressing the physicians' training, attitudes, and utilization of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) therapies, compared to the well-documented escalating use of CAM among consumers. Patients who use CAM, however often do not disclose their utilization to their physicians. This study thus surveyed knowledge, attitudes, and practices of complementary and alternative medicine among physicians on the island of Oahu in Hawaii. The Hawaii Medical Service Association (HMSA) provided physicians' names and contact information.
METHOD
This is a descriptive study with a questionnaire that was mailed to all physicians on the list. A total of 299 physicians responded to this survey. Response rate was 17.45%.
RESULTS
Physicians reported having moderate acknowledge in acupuncture, massage, prayer/spiritualty chiropractic, hypnosis and meditation. They recognized the value of these treatments and refer their patients to have these treatments. On the other hand, homeopathy naturopathy, electromagnetic therapies, therapeutic/healing touch, and nutriceuticals were consistently rated as having no role in conventional medicine, strongly opposed to in practice, or would not refer patients to. Respondents felt CAM could be most effective for pain, musculoskeletal, psychological conditions and smoking cessation.
DISCUSSIONS
Results indicated that the respondents had knowledge about prayer/spirituality, massage, chiropractic, meditation, hypnosis, and acupuncture, and also rated them as playing a role in conventional medicine, and would refer or have referred patients to. When they had little knowledge about naturopathy, electromagnetic therapies, nutriceuticals, and homeopathy, they rated these therapies as having no role in conventional medicine, and were strongly opposed to in practice or would not refer patients to. Respondents reported the least know abut the Aryurveda and Native American medicine. However, there was no significant correlation between negative attitude and practice patterns. Similarly therapeutic touch and chiropractic were perceived as therapies, but no role in conventional medicine although the respondents reported having some knowledge of these therapies. Thus, knowledge may not be necessarily associated with negative attitudes and practice patterns.
引言
与消费者对补充和替代医学(CAM)疗法的使用呈上升趋势且有充分记录相比,针对医生对CAM疗法的培训、态度及使用情况的研究较少。然而,使用CAM的患者往往不会向医生透露他们的使用情况。因此,本研究调查了夏威夷瓦胡岛上医生对补充和替代医学的知识、态度及实践情况。夏威夷医疗服务协会(HMSA)提供了医生的姓名和联系信息。
方法
这是一项描述性研究,通过向名单上的所有医生邮寄问卷进行。共有299名医生回复了此次调查。回复率为17.45%。
结果
医生们表示对针灸、按摩、祈祷/灵性、脊椎按摩疗法、催眠和冥想有一定了解。他们认识到这些治疗方法的价值,并会将患者转介去接受这些治疗。另一方面,顺势疗法、自然疗法、电磁疗法、治疗性/治愈性触摸和营养补充剂一直被认为在传统医学中没有作用,在实践中强烈反对使用,或不会将患者转介去接受这些治疗。受访者认为CAM对疼痛、肌肉骨骼疾病、心理状况和戒烟可能最有效。
讨论
结果表明,受访者对祈祷/灵性、按摩、脊椎按摩疗法、冥想、催眠和针灸有一定了解,并且认为它们在传统医学中发挥作用,并会或已经将患者转介去接受这些治疗。当他们对自然疗法、电磁疗法、营养补充剂和顺势疗法了解较少时,他们认为这些疗法在传统医学中没有作用,在实践中强烈反对使用或不会将患者转介去接受这些治疗。受访者表示对阿育吠陀医学和美国本土医学了解最少。然而,负面态度与实践模式之间没有显著相关性。同样,治疗性触摸和脊椎按摩疗法被视为疗法,但在传统医学中没有作用,尽管受访者表示对这些疗法有一定了解。因此,知识不一定与负面态度和实践模式相关。