Musher Daniel M, Montoya Roberto, Wanahita Anna
Infectious Disease Section, Medical Service, Veterans Affairs Medical Center, Department of Medicine, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, Texas 77030, USA.
Clin Infect Dis. 2004 Jul 15;39(2):165-9. doi: 10.1086/421497. Epub 2004 Jul 1.
Clinicians continue to question the usefulness of microscopic examination of Gram-stained sputum specimens ("Gram staining") and sputum culture for diagnosis of pneumonia. We analyzed the sensitivity of these techniques in 105 patients with pneumococcal pneumonia proven by blood culture. Gram staining revealed gram-positive cocci in pairs and chains, and culture yielded pneumococci in only 31% and 44% of all cases, respectively. However, sputum specimens were never submitted for examination in 31 cases; in 16 others, the specimen was inadequate and a culture was not done. Excluding these cases, the sensitivities of Gram staining and culture were 57% and 79%, respectively. If patients receiving antibiotics for >24 h had been excluded, Gram staining would have suggested pneumococci in 63%, and culture results would have been positive in 86%. Sensitivity increased in inverse proportion to the duration of antibiotic therapy (P<.05). Microscopic examination of sputum samples before antibiotics were administered and performance of culture within 24 h of receipt of such treatment yielded the correct diagnosis in >80% of cases of pneumococcal pneumonia.
临床医生仍在质疑对革兰氏染色痰液标本进行显微镜检查(“革兰氏染色”)以及痰液培养对肺炎诊断的实用性。我们分析了这些技术在105例经血培养证实为肺炎球菌肺炎患者中的敏感性。革兰氏染色显示成双和呈链状的革兰氏阳性球菌,而培养分别仅在所有病例的31%和44%中培养出肺炎球菌。然而,有31例从未送检痰液标本;另有16例标本不合格,未进行培养。排除这些病例后,革兰氏染色和培养的敏感性分别为57%和79%。如果排除接受抗生素治疗超过24小时的患者,革兰氏染色提示肺炎球菌的比例为63%,培养结果阳性率为86%。敏感性与抗生素治疗持续时间成反比(P<0.05)。在使用抗生素之前对痰液样本进行显微镜检查,并在接受此类治疗后24小时内进行培养,在超过80%的肺炎球菌肺炎病例中可得出正确诊断。