Vieira M L C, Grinberg M, Pomerantzeff P M A, Andrade J L, Mansur A J
Heart Institute (InCor), University of São Paulo Medical School, Brazil.
Heart. 2004 Sep;90(9):1020-4. doi: 10.1136/hrt.2003.025585.
To study the diagnostic contribution of repeated transthoracic (TTE) and transoesophageal echocardiography (TOE) among patients with suspected infective endocarditis.
262 patients with 266 episodes of suspected infective endocarditis were referred for TTE and TOE over three years in a 423 bed university cardiology hospital. Patients were a mean (SD) of 47.6 (17.9) years old. 139 (52.3%) episodes occurred in men and 127 (47.7%) in women. The diagnostic information obtained from repeated TTE and TOE examinations was evaluated relative to the diagnosis of endocarditis.
TTE examinations were repeated in 192 (72.2%) and TOE examinations were repeated in 49 (18.4%) of 266 episodes. A mean of 2.4 TTE and 1.2 TOE examinations were performed for each episode of suspected endocarditis. The second and third TTEs added diagnostic information in 34 (26.7%) and the second and third TOEs added diagnostic information in 25 (19.7%) of 127 episodes with definite endocarditis. After the third TTE or TOE no additional diagnostic information was obtained.
The diagnostic contribution of repeated TTE or TOE for the diagnosis of endocarditis decreased as the number of repetitions increased. In this setting, the data do not substantiate more than three TTE or TOE examinations as an efficient strategy to increase the diagnostic yield for all but selected patients with suspected endocarditis.
研究经胸超声心动图(TTE)和经食管超声心动图(TOE)重复检查对疑似感染性心内膜炎患者的诊断价值。
在一家拥有423张床位的大学心脏病医院,三年内262例患者出现266次疑似感染性心内膜炎发作,接受了TTE和TOE检查。患者平均年龄为47.6(17.9)岁。男性发作139次(52.3%),女性发作127次(47.7%)。将重复TTE和TOE检查获得的诊断信息与心内膜炎的诊断进行对比评估。
266次发作中,192次(72.2%)重复进行了TTE检查,49次(18.4%)重复进行了TOE检查。每次疑似心内膜炎发作平均进行2.4次TTE检查和1.2次TOE检查。在127例确诊心内膜炎的发作中,第二次和第三次TTE检查分别在34例(26.7%)中增加了诊断信息,第二次和第三次TOE检查分别在25例(19.7%)中增加了诊断信息。第三次TTE或TOE检查后未获得额外的诊断信息。
重复TTE或TOE对心内膜炎诊断的贡献随着重复次数的增加而降低。在此情况下,除部分疑似感染性心内膜炎患者外,数据无法证实超过三次TTE或TOE检查是提高诊断率的有效策略。