Weber Oliver M, Pujadas Sandra, Martin Alastair J, Higgins Charles B
Department of Radiology, University of California, San Francisco, USA.
J Magn Reson Imaging. 2004 Sep;20(3):395-402. doi: 10.1002/jmri.20141.
To compare six free-breathing, three-dimensional, magnetization-prepared coronary magnetic resonance angiography (MRA) sequences.
Six bright-blood sequences were evaluated: Cartesian segmented gradient echo (C-SGE), radial SGE (R-SGE), spiral SGE (S-SGE), spiral gradient echo (S-GE), Cartesian steady-state free precession (C-SSFP), and radial SSFP (R-SSFP). The right coronary artery (RCA) was imaged in 10 healthy volunteers using all six sequences in randomized order. Images were evaluated by two observers with respect to signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR), visible vessel length, vessel edge sharpness, and vessel diameter.
C-SSFP depicted RCA over the longest distance with high vessel sharpness, good SNR, and excellent background suppression. S-GE provided best SNR and CNR in proximal segments, but more vessel blurring and poorer background suppression, resulting in poor visualization of distal segments. R-SSFP images showed good background suppression and best vessel sharpness, but only moderate SNR. C-SGE provided good SNR and reasonable CNR, but lowest vessel sharpness. S-SGE and R-SGE visualized the RCA over the smallest distance, mostly due to vessel blurring and low SNR, respectively.
Overall, Cartesian SSFP provided the best image quality with excellent vessel sharpness, visualization of long vessel segments, and good SNR and CNR.
比较六种自由呼吸三维磁化准备冠状动脉磁共振血管造影(MRA)序列。
评估六种亮血序列:笛卡尔分段梯度回波(C-SGE)、径向梯度回波(R-SGE)、螺旋梯度回波(S-SGE)、螺旋梯度回波(S-GE)、笛卡尔稳态自由进动(C-SSFP)和径向稳态自由进动(R-SSFP)。对10名健康志愿者的右冠状动脉(RCA)使用所有六种序列按随机顺序进行成像。由两名观察者对图像的信噪比(SNR)、对比噪声比(CNR)、可见血管长度;血管边缘清晰度和血管直径进行评估。
C-SSFP显示RCA的距离最长,血管清晰度高,信噪比良好,背景抑制效果优异。S-GE在近端节段提供了最佳的SNR和CNR,但血管模糊更多,背景抑制较差,导致远端节段可视化不佳。R-SSFP图像显示出良好的背景抑制和最佳的血管清晰度,但SNR仅为中等。C-SGE提供了良好的SNR和合理的CNR,但血管清晰度最低。S-SGE和R-SGE分别由于血管模糊和低SNR,显示RCA的距离最短。
总体而言,笛卡尔SSFP提供了最佳的图像质量,具有出色的血管清晰度、长血管节段的可视化以及良好的SNR和CNR。