Klein D F, Mannuzza S, Chapman T, Fyer A J
Department of Therapeutics, New York State Psychiatric Institute.
J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 1992 Jan;31(1):112-4; discussion 114-6. doi: 10.1097/00004583-199201000-00017.
Childhood panic attacks and panic disorder were assessed retrospectively in adult anxiety clinic patients (N = 343) and their adult relatives (N = 560). Only nine (1%) of the 903 subjects were judged to have experienced spontaneous panic attacks before age 13 by clinically trained interviewers. The narrative summaries of these cases were reviewed, and only three of nine provided convincing descriptions of spontaneous panic attacks in childhood. The authors conclude that prepubertal spontaneous panic attacks are rare, and that retrospective assessments of panic phenomena are difficult, even among adequately trained mental health professionals.
对成人焦虑症门诊患者(N = 343)及其成年亲属(N = 560)进行了回顾性评估,以了解童年期惊恐发作和惊恐障碍的情况。在903名受试者中,只有9名(1%)经临床训练的访谈者判断在13岁之前经历过自发性惊恐发作。对这些病例的叙述性总结进行了审查,9例中只有3例对童年期自发性惊恐发作提供了令人信服的描述。作者得出结论,青春期前的自发性惊恐发作很少见,而且即使在训练有素的心理健康专业人员中,对惊恐现象的回顾性评估也很困难。