Musal Berna, Gursel Yucel, Taskiran H Cahit, Ozan Sema, Tuna Arif
Medical Education Department, Dokuz Eylul School of Medicine, Inciralti, Izmir, Turkey.
BMC Med Educ. 2004 Sep 22;4:16. doi: 10.1186/1472-6920-4-16.
The objective of this study is to investigate the perceptions of first and third year medical students on self-study and reporting processes of Problem-based Learning (PBL) sessions and their usage of learning resources.
The questionnaire applied to the students consisted of; questions about students' perceptions on searching and preparing phases of the self-study process, the breadth and depth of discussion during reporting phase and the usage of learning resources.
First-year students spent more time for self-study and more highly rated the depth of discussion compared to third-year students. The searching and preparing phases of the self-study process were considered as statistically important factors strongly influencing the breadth and depth of discussion during the reporting phase. The effect of extensiveness of searching on the depth of discussion was negative among the first-year students, and positive among third-year students.
The relative shortness of third-year students' self-study periods can be related to their mental weariness, decreased motivation or first-year students' slowness in accessing appropriate resources. The third-year students' more frequent use of textbooks may be due to the improvement of their abilities in reaching relevant learning resources. The findings implied that the increase in students' PBL experience paralleled the development of their discussion skills using different learning resources.
本研究的目的是调查一年级和三年级医学生对基于问题的学习(PBL)课程的自学和汇报过程的看法以及他们对学习资源的使用情况。
向学生发放的问卷包括:关于学生对自学过程中搜索和准备阶段的看法、汇报阶段讨论的广度和深度以及学习资源使用情况的问题。
与三年级学生相比,一年级学生花费更多时间自学,并且对讨论深度的评价更高。自学过程中的搜索和准备阶段被认为是对汇报阶段讨论的广度和深度有强烈影响的统计学重要因素。在一年级学生中,搜索的广泛性对讨论深度的影响为负,而在三年级学生中为正。
三年级学生自学时间相对较短可能与他们的精神疲劳、动力下降或一年级学生获取合适资源较慢有关。三年级学生更频繁地使用教科书可能是由于他们获取相关学习资源的能力有所提高。研究结果表明,学生PBL经验的增加与他们使用不同学习资源的讨论技巧的发展同步。