Kraft G H, Fitts S S, Hammond M C
Department of Rehabilitation Medicine, University of Washington, Seattle 98195.
Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 1992 Mar;73(3):220-7.
We evaluated functional improvement in the upper limb of chronic (more than six months' duration) stroke patients who received one of two electrical stimulation treatments, conventional treatment, or no treatment. Twenty-two right-handed patients were assigned to one of four groups studied for 12 months posttreatment. Subjects received (1) EMG-initiated electrical stimulation of wrist extensors (EMG-stim), (2) low-intensity electrical stimulation of wrist extensors combined with voluntary contractions (B/B), (3) proprioceptive neuromuscular facilitation (PNF) exercises, or (4) no treatment. Subjects were treated for three months. Before treatment, upon completion of treatment, and three and nine months after treatment, subjects were evaluated by the Fugl-Meyer (FM) poststroke motor recovery test and by grip strength. Subjects also attempted three Jebsen-Taylor hand function tests and a finger tapping test at the same evaluation sessions, but many were unable to complete these tests. During the course of treatment, FM scores of subjects receiving PNF improved 18%, B/B improved 25%, and EMG-stim improved 42%. The aggregate FM improvement of the treated groups was significant from pretreatment to posttreatment, and the improvement was maintained at three-month and nine-month followups (all p less than .005). The treated subjects' improvement in grip strength was also maintained at both followups (p less than .10). In contrast, the control group showed no significant change in FM scores or grip strength. The four treated subjects who were able to perform the hand function tests and finger tapping at all four evaluations also improved on these tests.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
我们评估了接受两种电刺激治疗之一、传统治疗或不接受治疗的慢性(病程超过6个月)中风患者上肢功能的改善情况。22名右利手患者被分配到四组中的一组,在治疗后进行12个月的研究。受试者接受(1)肌电图启动的腕伸肌电刺激(肌电图刺激),(2)腕伸肌低强度电刺激结合自主收缩(B/B),(3)本体感觉神经肌肉促进法(PNF)练习,或(4)不接受治疗。受试者接受为期三个月的治疗。在治疗前、治疗结束时以及治疗后三个月和九个月,通过Fugl-Meyer(FM)中风后运动恢复测试和握力对受试者进行评估。受试者还在相同的评估阶段尝试了三项Jebsen-Taylor手功能测试和一项手指敲击测试,但许多人无法完成这些测试。在治疗过程中,接受PNF治疗的受试者的FM评分提高了18%,B/B提高了25%,肌电图刺激提高了42%。从治疗前到治疗后,治疗组FM评分的总体改善具有显著性,并且在三个月和九个月的随访中这种改善得以维持(所有p值均小于0.005)。在两次随访中,接受治疗的受试者握力也有所改善(p值小于0.10)。相比之下,对照组的FM评分或握力没有显著变化。在所有四次评估中都能够进行手功能测试和手指敲击的四名接受治疗的受试者在这些测试中也有所改善。(摘要截选至250字)