利扎曲普坦与非曲坦类常规护理药物治疗偏头痛:一项基于药房的研究。
Migraine treatment with rizatriptan and non-triptan usual care medications: a pharmacy-based study.
作者信息
Cady Roger, Martin Vincent, Adelman James, Diamond Merle, Sajjan Shiva, Hu X Henry
机构信息
Headache Care Center, Primary Care Network, Inc., Springfield, MO, USA.
出版信息
Headache. 2004 Oct;44(9):900-7. doi: 10.1111/j.1526-4610.2004.04172.x.
OBJECTIVE
To compare the effectiveness of rizatriptan to other non-triptan medications in the relief of migraine headache in usual care settings.
BACKGROUND
Although rizatriptan has been shown to provide effective relief of migraine symptoms in clinical trials, limited data exist directly comparing its effectiveness with non-triptan medications.
METHODS
Migraineurs aged 18 to 55 who had been prescribed a new antimigraine drug (rizatriptan 10 mg or a selected class of non-triptan oral medications) were recruited to participate in the study through a national retail pharmacy chain. Participants completed a baseline questionnaire at the enrollment and reported their treatment experiences by filling out the treatment diary after using the newly prescribed medication. The treatment outcomes of patients receiving rizatriptan were compared with those receiving non-triptan medications. Logistic regression analysis was applied to test statistical significance with adjustment for potential confounding factors.
RESULTS
Of the 728 patients who entered the study, 693 (95.2%) completed the treatment diary. Patients treated with rizatriptan (192) and non-triptans (501) reported the following outcomes, respectively--onset of headache relief within 30 minutes post-dose: 25% versus 18%; self-defined significant headache relief within 2 hours post-dose: 71% versus 54%; pain free or mild pain at 2 hours post-dose: 58% versus 47%; completely symptom-free within 2 hours of post-dose: 32% versus 20%; return to usual activities within 2 hours post-dose: 39% versus 35%; and satisfied with treatment: 67% versus 55% (P <.05 in all comparisons with exception of returning to usual activities).
CONCLUSION
Rizatriptan was significantly more effective than non-triptans in the relief of migraine headaches for patients obtaining prescribed migraine medications from a retail pharmacy. Additional studies at other usual care settings may be needed to confirm the findings.
目的
比较在常规护理环境中,利扎曲普坦与其他非曲坦类药物缓解偏头痛的效果。
背景
尽管在临床试验中已证明利扎曲普坦能有效缓解偏头痛症状,但直接将其与非曲坦类药物的疗效进行比较的数据有限。
方法
通过全国连锁零售药店招募年龄在18至55岁、已开具新的抗偏头痛药物(10毫克利扎曲普坦或某类选定的非曲坦类口服药物)的偏头痛患者参与研究。参与者在入组时完成一份基线问卷,并在使用新开具的药物后通过填写治疗日记报告其治疗体验。将接受利扎曲普坦治疗的患者的治疗结果与接受非曲坦类药物治疗的患者进行比较。应用逻辑回归分析来检验统计学意义,并对潜在的混杂因素进行调整。
结果
在728名进入研究的患者中,693名(95.2%)完成了治疗日记。接受利扎曲普坦治疗的患者(192名)和接受非曲坦类药物治疗的患者(501名)分别报告了以下结果——服药后30分钟内头痛缓解的发生率:25%对18%;服药后2小时内自我定义的显著头痛缓解率:71%对54%;服药后2小时无痛或轻度疼痛率:58%对47%;服药后2小时内完全无症状率:32%对20%;服药后2小时内恢复正常活动率:39%对35%;对治疗满意的比例:67%对55%(除恢复正常活动外,所有比较的P值均<.05)。
结论
对于从零售药店获得处方偏头痛药物的患者,利扎曲普坦在缓解偏头痛方面明显比非曲坦类药物更有效。可能需要在其他常规护理环境中进行更多研究以证实这些发现