Shapiro S A, Scully T
Department of Surgery, Indiana University Medical Center, Indianapolis.
Neurosurgery. 1992 Feb;30(2):241-5. doi: 10.1227/00006123-199202000-00015.
One hundred and seven patients who had a lumbar subarachnoid catheter (teflon or silicone) placed for closed continuous cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) drainage between 1983-1991 are presented. Overall, the drain was successful in achieving the desired goal in 101 of 107 (94%) cases. There were no deaths. Five of 107 (5%) patients developed infections including two cases (2%) of meningitis. There were three cases (3%) of overdrainage with temporary neurologic decline, but all recovered. Five of fifteen (33%) teflon catheters required replacement because of occlusion, but only 5 of 92 (5%) silicone catheters required replacement. Transient lumbar nerve root irritation was seen in 15 of 107 (14%) patients treated for a CSF fistula, and all symptoms resolved after drain removal. CSF fistula/pseudomeningocele after spine surgery was cured by CSF drainage in 36 of 39 (92%) cases; there was a 10% incidence of infection (1 wound, 2 discitis, 1 meningitis). CSF fistula after cranial surgery was cured in 22 of 25 (87%) cases; there was 1 case of (4%) infection and 1 case (4%) of overdrainage. A drain was used to augment a tenuous dural closure in 38 patients with 100% success; no infection occurred and there were 2 cases (5%) of overdrainage. Five patients were successfully treated for traumatic CSF rhinorrhea/otorrhea without complications. The silicone catheter appears superior to the teflon catheter; however, both are simple, safe, and efficacious for the treatment or prevention of CSF fistulas.
本文报告了1983年至1991年间107例因行腰蛛网膜下腔置管(聚四氟乙烯或硅胶材质)以进行封闭式持续脑脊液引流的患者情况。总体而言,在107例患者中,有101例(94%)引流成功达到预期目标。无死亡病例。107例患者中有5例(5%)发生感染,其中包括2例(2%)脑膜炎。有3例(3%)出现过度引流伴短暂神经功能减退,但均恢复。15根聚四氟乙烯导管中有5根(33%)因堵塞需要更换,而92根硅胶导管中只有5根(5%)需要更换。在107例因脑脊液瘘接受治疗的患者中,有15例(14%)出现短暂性腰神经根刺激症状,拔除引流管后所有症状均消失。脊柱手术后脑脊液瘘/假性脑脊膜膨出在39例中有36例(92%)通过脑脊液引流治愈;感染发生率为10%(1例伤口感染、2例椎间盘炎、1例脑膜炎)。颅脑手术后脑脊液瘘在25例中有22例(87%)治愈;有1例(4%)感染和1例(4%)过度引流。38例患者使用引流管加强薄弱的硬脑膜闭合,成功率为100%;未发生感染,有2例(5%)过度引流。5例患者成功治疗外伤性脑脊液鼻漏/耳漏,无并发症发生。硅胶导管似乎优于聚四氟乙烯导管;然而,两者在治疗或预防脑脊液瘘方面都简单、安全且有效。