Choi Kyung-Hee, Wojcicki Janet, Valencia-Garcia Dellanira
Center for AIDS Prevention Studies, University of California, San Francisco, California 94105, USA.
AIDS Behav. 2004 Sep;8(3):251-61. doi: 10.1023/B:AIBE.0000044073.74932.6f.
Safe sex skills training often teach women to be assertive in condom use negotiations. However, it has been suggested that assertiveness training may be inappropriate for women who lack power in their sexual relationship. Our qualitative study of 62 women attending a family planning clinic explored various communication styles they used to introduce and negotiate female condom use in their sexual relationships. We further examined how different introduction and negotiation styles were related to actual use of the device. The device was introduced using a direct, semidirect, indirect, or nonverbal communication approach. Use of the female condom was negotiated by avoiding sex, using humor, discussing the possibility of using the condom, or being argumentative with partners. The outcome of introducing and negotiating female condom use was often mediated by other factors including partner characteristics, relationship power dynamics, situational context, and use of additional discourse strategies (e.g., describing the female condom as a sexual toy or taking the opportunity to educated partners about the female condom). Less direct approaches appeared to be as effective in facilitating use of the female condom as more direct approaches. Female condom introduction and negotiation styles that continued to engage their partners by using additional discourse strategies led to more frequent use of the device. Implications of our findings for HIV risk reduction program development are discussed.
安全性行为技能培训通常教导女性在避孕套使用谈判中要坚定自信。然而,有人认为,坚定自信培训可能不适用于在性关系中缺乏权力的女性。我们对62名前往计划生育诊所的女性进行了定性研究,探讨了她们在性关系中介绍和协商使用女用避孕套时所采用的各种沟通方式。我们进一步研究了不同的介绍和协商方式与该器具实际使用情况之间的关系。介绍女用避孕套时采用了直接、半直接、间接或非语言沟通方式。协商使用女用避孕套的方式包括避免性行为、使用幽默、讨论使用避孕套的可能性或与伴侣争论。介绍和协商使用女用避孕套的结果往往受到其他因素的调节,这些因素包括伴侣特征、关系中的权力动态、情境背景以及使用其他话语策略(例如,将女用避孕套描述为性玩具或借此机会向伴侣介绍女用避孕套)。不太直接的方式在促进女用避孕套使用方面似乎与更直接的方式一样有效。通过使用其他话语策略继续与伴侣互动的女用避孕套介绍和协商方式导致该器具的使用更为频繁。我们讨论了研究结果对减少艾滋病毒风险项目开发的启示。