Dåderman Anna M, Lindgren May, Lidberg Lars
Department of Psychology, Stockholm University, Sweden.
Nord J Psychiatry. 2004;58(5):371-81. doi: 10.1080/08039480410005936.
The prevalence of dyslexia and attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (AD/HD) (DSM-IV) is markedly increased among those who are sentenced for criminal offences. The aim of the study was to identify developmental disabilities, dyslexia and AD/HD among severely disturbed men in forensic psychiatric care, and to study the co-occurrence of such disabilities, with the objective to discuss the importance of the diagnoses in forensic psychiatry. The participants were 10 males who had committed rape on adult women, and included two murder-rapists, one of which had murdered more than one victim (i.e. a serial murderer). All had been assigned to special long-term forensic psychiatric care, based predominantly on a psychodynamic ground. In order to be identified as having dyslexia, a participant's performance on at least three out of four tests of academic skills had to be markedly below the expected level (more than two stanine steps), given the participant's non-verbal intellectual capacity and considering the length of his education. AD/HD was investigated by studying the participants' forensic psychiatric files and by a clinical interview. Seven of the 10 participants met the DSM-IV criteria for dyslexia, and six of them met the DSM-IV criteria for AD/HD. Four participants had AD/HD and dyslexia, three had AD/HD but no dyslexia, and two had dyslexia but no AD/HD. Only one participant had neither dyslexia nor AD/HD. The participants with dyslexia performed well in tests assessing non-verbal reasoning, visuo-spatial capacity and visual memory. Although the generalization of the results from 10 rapists is severely limited, the results indicate the importance of assessing dyslexia as well as AD/HD in people who are admitted for forensic psychiatric assessment. The lack of correct diagnoses may negatively influence the choice of appropriate forensic psychiatric care. Early assessment of those disorders might have a positive influence on the psychological development and socialization process in people with dyslexia and/or AD/HD.
在因刑事犯罪被判刑的人群中,诵读困难症和注意力缺陷多动障碍(AD/HD,依据《精神疾病诊断与统计手册第四版》[DSM-IV])的患病率显著升高。本研究的目的是确定在法医精神病护理机构中病情严重紊乱的男性群体中的发育障碍、诵读困难症和AD/HD,并研究这些障碍的共现情况,以便讨论这些诊断在法医精神病学中的重要性。研究参与者为10名成年女性强奸犯,其中包括两名谋杀强奸犯,其中一人谋杀了不止一名受害者(即连环杀手)。所有人都主要基于心理动力学原因被安排接受特殊的长期法医精神病护理。为了被认定患有诵读困难症,考虑到参与者的非语言智力水平及其受教育时长,其在四项学术技能测试中至少三项的表现必须显著低于预期水平(超过两个标准九分等级)。通过研究参与者的法医精神病档案并进行临床访谈来调查AD/HD。10名参与者中有7人符合DSM-IV的诵读困难症标准,其中6人符合DSM-IV的AD/HD标准。4名参与者同时患有AD/HD和诵读困难症,3名参与者患有AD/HD但无诵读困难症,2名参与者患有诵读困难症但无AD/HD。只有1名参与者既无诵读困难症也无AD/HD。患有诵读困难症的参与者在评估非语言推理、视觉空间能力和视觉记忆的测试中表现良好。尽管从10名强奸犯得出的结果推广性严重受限,但结果表明在接受法医精神病评估的人群中评估诵读困难症以及AD/HD的重要性。缺乏正确诊断可能会对选择合适的法医精神病护理产生负面影响。对这些障碍的早期评估可能会对患有诵读困难症和/或AD/HD的人的心理发展和社会化进程产生积极影响。