Statham J
Thomas Coram Research Unit, Institute of Education, University of London, London, UK.
Child Care Health Dev. 2004 Nov;30(6):589-98. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2214.2004.00472.x.
Children living in special circumstances, defined as those who are at risk of achieving poorer outcomes than their peers, have a particular need of good quality, accessible services to promote their health and well-being, yet may be least likely to receive them.
This review considers the evidence for effective services to support children living in five kinds of special circumstances: (1) those at risk of offending; (2) teenage parents; (3) children whose parents have drug, alcohol or mental health problems; (4) children living with domestic violence; and (5) children who have been abused or neglected. In practice, there is often considerable overlap between these groups, and many children face multiple disadvantage. The review also aims to identify effective strategies for making support services more accessible to hard-to-reach groups.
Relevant literature was identified through searches of databases and websites, and consultation with experts. Given the broad scope of the topic, the aim was to provide an overview of best evidence rather than to undertake a systematic review.
Similar themes underpin the most promising approaches to supporting children in special circumstances. These include: (1) a holistic, multi-agency approach addressing the needs of the whole child rather than compartmentalising children's social, educational, health and care needs; (2) the importance of links between adults' and children's services so that children who are in need because of their parents' circumstances can be identified and supported; and (3) the value of providing children in special circumstances with intensive, targeted support within a framework of universal provision.
Overall, there is a lack of well-designed evaluations of the effectiveness of UK services and programmes for children in special circumstances. The existing evidence base would be strengthened by the development of better outcome measures, by exploring the characteristics of effective services from the perspective of different stakeholders (including children and young people themselves) and by extending the current problem-oriented approach to consider the factors that promote resilience and coping.
生活在特殊环境中的儿童,即那些比同龄人更有可能面临不良后果风险的儿童,特别需要优质且可获得的服务来促进他们的健康和幸福,但他们获得这些服务的可能性可能最小。
本综述考察了为生活在五种特殊环境中的儿童提供有效服务的证据:(1)有犯罪风险的儿童;(2)青少年父母;(3)父母有药物、酒精或心理健康问题的儿童;(4)生活在家庭暴力环境中的儿童;(5)遭受虐待或忽视的儿童。在实际情况中,这些群体之间往往有相当大的重叠,许多儿童面临多重不利处境。本综述还旨在确定有效的策略,以使难以接触到的群体更容易获得支持服务。
通过搜索数据库和网站以及咨询专家来确定相关文献。鉴于该主题范围广泛,目的是提供最佳证据的概述,而非进行系统综述。
支持特殊环境中儿童的最有前景的方法有一些相似的主题。这些包括:(1)一种整体的、多机构的方法,满足儿童的整体需求,而不是将儿童的社会、教育、健康和照料需求分割开来;(2)成人服务与儿童服务之间建立联系的重要性,以便能够识别并支持那些因父母情况而有需求的儿童;(3)在普遍提供服务的框架内,为特殊环境中的儿童提供强化的、有针对性的支持的价值。
总体而言,对于英国为特殊环境中儿童提供的服务和项目的有效性,缺乏精心设计的评估。通过制定更好的成果衡量标准、从不同利益相关者(包括儿童和年轻人自身)的角度探索有效服务的特征,以及扩展当前以问题为导向的方法来考虑促进恢复力和应对能力的因素,可以加强现有的证据基础。