Appenzeller Otto, Amm Marita, Jones Howard
NMHEMC Research Foundation, Albuquerque, NM 87122-1424, USA.
J Hist Neurosci. 2004 Dec;13(4):345-50. doi: 10.1080/09647040490881677.
The invention of realistic portraiture to reveal "inner life" is attributed by some art historians to Jan van Eyck who worked in Flanders from 1420 onwards. We show, using clinical neurological examination of the gold mask of Agamemnon dating from 1550-1500 BC and of the portraits of Henry III and his son Edward I -- important English royals -- painted between 1216 and 1307, that realistic portraits were made well before the 15th Century. Thus artists unwittingly used neurology as part of their realistic approach to the presentation of the face. Because neurological diagnosis is often visual, neurology, in turn, has a rich potential to unveil examples of realism in art. We consider the art pieces examined here also pertinent to art historians, as they assess the role of art in documenting history.
一些艺术史学家将揭示“内心生活”的写实肖像画的发明归功于扬·凡·艾克,他于1420年起在佛兰德斯工作。我们通过对公元前1550 - 1500年的阿伽门农金面具以及1216年至1307年间绘制的重要英国皇室成员亨利三世和他的儿子爱德华一世的肖像进行临床神经学检查表明,写实肖像早在15世纪之前就已出现。因此,艺术家们在不知不觉中把神经学作为他们呈现面部写实手法的一部分。由于神经学诊断通常是通过视觉进行的,反过来,神经学在揭示艺术中的写实范例方面具有丰富的潜力。我们认为这里所研究的艺术作品对艺术史学家也具有相关性,因为他们评估艺术在记录历史中的作用。