Leung K Y, Lee C P, Tang M H Y, Lau E T, Ng L K L, Lee Y P, Chan H Y, Ma E S K, Chan Vivian
Department of Obstetrics & Gynaecology, The University of Hong Kong, Queen Mary Hospital, Hong Kong SAR, China.
Prenat Diagn. 2004 Nov;24(11):899-907. doi: 10.1002/pd.1035.
To determine the cost effectiveness of a universal prenatal screening program for alpha- and beta-thalassaemia.
We retrospectively reviewed our program from 1998 to 2002, and calculated the direct and indirect costs of various components.
18,936 women were screened at our prenatal clinic and 153 couples were subsequently referred to our Prenatal Diagnostic Centre for counselling and further investigations. In addition, there were 238 tertiary referrals and 157 self-referrals. After investigations, 84 fetuses were at risk of beta-thalassaemia major/beta-E thalassaemia, 19 of them were affected and 18 were aborted. The total expenditure on our program (HK 10.0 million dollars) would be less than the postnatal service costs (HK 40.4 million dollars) for 18beta-thalassaemia major fetuses if they were born. Of 361 women at risk of carrying a homozygous alpha0-thalassaemia fetus, 311 (86.2%) opted for the indirect approach (using serial ultrasound examinations to exclude Hb Bart's disease), and 76 (24.5%) subsequently underwent an invasive test for a definitive diagnosis. The sensitivity and false positive rate of this indirect approach was 100.0% and 2.9% respectively.
It is cost effective to run a universal prenatal screening program in an area where both beta-thalassaemia and alpha-thalassaemia are prevalent. The indirect approach can effectively avoid an invasive test in unaffected pregnancies.
确定一项针对α和β地中海贫血的通用产前筛查项目的成本效益。
我们回顾性分析了1998年至2002年的项目情况,并计算了各个组成部分的直接和间接成本。
在我们的产前诊所对18936名女性进行了筛查,随后有153对夫妇被转介到我们的产前诊断中心进行咨询和进一步检查。此外,还有238例三级转诊和157例自我转诊。经过检查,84例胎儿有患重型β地中海贫血/β-E地中海贫血的风险,其中19例受影响,18例被终止妊娠。如果18例重型β地中海贫血胎儿出生,我们项目的总支出(1000万港元)将低于其产后服务成本(4040万港元)。在361例有携带纯合子α0地中海贫血胎儿风险的女性中,311例(86.2%)选择了间接方法(使用系列超声检查排除巴氏胎儿水肿综合征),76例(24.5%)随后接受了侵入性检查以明确诊断。这种间接方法的敏感性和假阳性率分别为100.0%和2.9%。
在β地中海贫血和α地中海贫血都流行的地区开展通用产前筛查项目具有成本效益。间接方法可以有效避免对未受影响的妊娠进行侵入性检查。