Bahl Rajiv, Sinha Anju, Poulos Christine, Whittington Dale, Sazawal Sunil, Kumar Ramesh, Mahalanabis Dilip, Acosta Camilo J, Clemens John D, Bhan Maharaj K
Centre for Diarrhoeal Disease and Nutrition Research, Department of Paediatrics, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi 110 029, India.
J Health Popul Nutr. 2004 Sep;22(3):304-10.
Data on the burden of disease, costs of illness, and cost-effectiveness of vaccines are needed to facilitate the use of available anti-typhoid vaccines in developing countries. This one-year prospective surveillance was carried out in an urban slum community in Delhi, India, to estimate the costs of illness for cases of typhoid fever. Ninety-eight culture-positive typhoid, 31 culture-positive paratyphoid, and 94 culture-negative cases with clinical typhoid syndrome were identified during the surveillance. Estimates of costs of illness were based on data collected through weekly interviews conducted at home for three months following diagnosis. Private costs included the sum of direct medical, direct non-medical, and indirect costs. Non-patient (public) costs included costs of outpatient visits, hospitalizations, laboratory tests, and medicines provided free of charge to the families. The mean cost per episode of blood culture-confirmed typhoid fever was 3,597 Indian Rupees (US$ 1=INR 35.5) (SD 5,833); hospitalization increased the costs by several folds (INR 18,131, SD 11,218, p<0.0001). The private and non-patient costs of illness were similar (INR 1,732, SD 1,589, and INR 1,865, SD 5,154 respectively, p=0.8095). The total private and non-patient ex-ante costs, i.e. expected annual losses for each individual, were higher for children aged 2-5 years (INR 154) than for those aged 5-19 years (INR 32), 0-2 year(s) (INR 25), and 19-40 years (INR 2). The study highlights the need for affordable typhoid vaccines efficacious at 2-5 years of age. Currently-available Vi vaccine is affordable but is unlikely to be efficacious in the first two years of life. Ways must be found to make Vi-conjugate vaccine, which is efficacious at this age, available to children of developing-countries.
为促进发展中国家使用现有的抗伤寒疫苗,需要有关疾病负担、疾病成本和疫苗成本效益的数据。在印度德里的一个城市贫民窟社区进行了为期一年的前瞻性监测,以估算伤寒热病例的疾病成本。在监测期间,共确定了98例培养阳性的伤寒病例、31例培养阳性的副伤寒病例和94例临床伤寒综合征培养阴性病例。疾病成本估计基于诊断后三个月在家中每周访谈收集的数据。私人成本包括直接医疗、直接非医疗和间接成本之和。非患者(公共)成本包括门诊就诊、住院、实验室检查以及免费提供给家庭的药品成本。血培养确诊的伤寒热每例平均成本为3597印度卢比(1美元 = 35.5印度卢比)(标准差5833);住院使成本增加了几倍(18131印度卢比,标准差11218,p<0.0001)。疾病的私人成本和非患者成本相似(分别为1732印度卢比,标准差1589,和1865印度卢比,标准差5154,p = 0.8095)。2至5岁儿童的私人和非患者事前总成本,即每个人的预期年度损失(154印度卢比)高于5至19岁(32印度卢比)、0至2岁(25印度卢比)和19至40岁(2印度卢比)的儿童。该研究强调需要有价格可承受且在2至5岁有效的伤寒疫苗。目前可用的Vi疫苗价格可承受,但在生命的头两年不太可能有效。必须找到方法,使在这个年龄段有效的Vi结合疫苗能够提供给发展中国家的儿童。