Schilling Lisa M, Steiner John F, Lundahl Kristy, Anderson Robert J
Department of Medicine, University of Colorado Health Sciences Center, Campus Box B212, 360 S. Garfield Avenue, Suite 685, Denver, CO 80209, USA.
Acad Med. 2005 Jan;80(1):51-6. doi: 10.1097/00001888-200501000-00013.
Resident physicians generate many patient-related questions in the outpatient setting, but rarely answer them. This study examined how answering a patient-specific clinical question affected residents' patient care decisions.
From October 2001 to June 2002, 43 internal medicine residents at the University of Colorado Health Sciences Center outpatient clinic formulated and attempted to answer specific clinical questions based on patients seen in the out-patient setting. Residents completed a questionnaire after finishing their clinical question exercise.
Residents completed 158 exercises (68%) out of 234 opportunities and found answers to 89% of questions (141/158). Questions most commonly addressed therapy (43%), diagnosis (15%), disease management (13%), and prevention (9%). The most frequently used methods to retrieve clinical information were Medline 73% (115/158) and UpToDate 70% (110/158). UpToDate (45%, 71/158) and journal articles (42%, 66/158) were the most helpful final information sources. Residents rated the impact of the information on a five-point scale (1 = strongly disagree; 5 = strongly agree) for the following: can be used to assist patient's care (mean 4.1), improved care (mean 4.0), improved communication (mean 4.3), improved confidence in care (mean 4.3), improved knowledge (mean 4.6), and will improve care for future patients (mean 4.4). The information affected clinical decision making in 78% (110/141) of cases.
Internal medicine residents practicing self-directed learning by answering patient-specific clinical questions reported improvement in knowledge and changes in patient care decisions.
住院医师在门诊环境中会产生许多与患者相关的问题,但很少自己解答这些问题。本研究探讨了回答针对特定患者的临床问题如何影响住院医师的患者护理决策。
2001年10月至2002年6月,科罗拉多大学健康科学中心门诊的43名内科住院医师根据门诊中见到的患者情况,提出并尝试回答特定的临床问题。住院医师在完成临床问题练习后填写了一份问卷。
住院医师在234次机会中完成了158次练习(68%),并找到了89%问题(141/158)的答案。最常涉及的问题是治疗(43%)、诊断(15%)、疾病管理(13%)和预防(9%)。检索临床信息最常用的方法是医学文献数据库(Medline,73%,115/158)和UpToDate(70%,110/158)。UpToDate(45%,71/158)和期刊文章(42%,66/158)是最有帮助的最终信息来源。住院医师对信息的影响在以下五点量表上进行评分(1 = 强烈不同意;5 = 强烈同意):可用于协助患者护理(平均4.1)、改善护理(平均4.0)、改善沟通(平均4.3)、提高护理信心(平均4.3);提高知识水平(平均4.6)以及将改善对未来患者的护理(平均4.4)。该信息在78%(110/141)的病例中影响了临床决策。
通过回答针对特定患者的临床问题进行自主学习的内科住院医师报告称,他们的知识有所提高,患者护理决策也发生了变化。