Graham Andrew, Davies Rhys, Xuereb John, Halliday Glenda, Kril Jillian, Creasey Helen, Graham Kim, Hodges John
MRC Cognition and Brain Sciences Unit, Addenbrooke's Hospital, Cambridge, UK.
Brain. 2005 Mar;128(Pt 3):597-605. doi: 10.1093/brain/awh348. Epub 2005 Jan 5.
Early and severe memory impairment is generally held to be an exclusion criterion for the clinical diagnosis of frontotemporal dementia (FTD). However, clinical experience suggests that some patients with otherwise typical FTD can be amnesic from presentation, or even present solely with amnesia. A review of severe amnesia at presentation in patients with pathologically proven FTD is therefore warranted. The present study examined the records of all patients in the joint Cambridge-Sydney neuropathological series of patients with dementia and a pathological diagnosis of FTD to identify those for whom memory complaints were dominant at presentation. Eight of 71 patients met these criteria. For two patients, memory loss was the only complaint; for one patient, memory loss was accompanied by personality change; for two patients, memory loss was accompanied by prominent dysexecutive symptoms; and for three patients, memory loss was accompanied by apathy but no other behavioural changes. In seven patients local specialist teams initially diagnosed Alzheimer's disease; four patients entered anticholinesterase drug trials. All eight later developed behavioural features: in four, the diagnosis was revised to FTD, while in four the diagnosis of FTD was made only on neuropathological examination after death. In conclusion, severe amnesia at presentation in FTD is commoner than previously thought and the clinical consensus criteria for the diagnosis of FTD may need to be revised. The underlying basis of the memory impairments in patients with FTD may be heterogeneous, with different explanations in different subgroups.
早期严重记忆障碍通常被视为额颞叶痴呆(FTD)临床诊断的排除标准。然而,临床经验表明,一些具有典型FTD症状的患者在发病时可能存在失忆症状,甚至仅表现为失忆。因此,有必要对经病理证实的FTD患者发病时的严重失忆情况进行综述。本研究检查了剑桥 - 悉尼联合神经病理学系列中所有痴呆患者且病理诊断为FTD患者的记录,以确定那些在发病时以记忆障碍为主诉的患者。71名患者中有8名符合这些标准。其中两名患者唯一的主诉是记忆力减退;一名患者记忆力减退伴有性格改变;两名患者记忆力减退伴有明显的执行功能障碍症状;三名患者记忆力减退伴有淡漠但无其他行为改变。7名患者最初由当地专科团队诊断为阿尔茨海默病;4名患者参加了抗胆碱酯酶药物试验。所有8名患者后来都出现了行为特征:4名患者诊断改为FTD,另外4名患者仅在死后经神经病理学检查才确诊为FTD。总之,FTD患者发病时的严重失忆比以前认为的更为常见,FTD诊断的临床共识标准可能需要修订。FTD患者记忆障碍的潜在原因可能是异质性的,不同亚组有不同的解释。