Fardal Oystein, Johannessen Anne C, Linden Gerard J
Oral Health Prev Dent. 2003;1(2):93-8.
Patients' compliance with periodontal maintenance therapy is important for the treatment outcomes, however, most studies report compliance rates ranging from only 11%-45%. The aims of this study were to report on the acceptance of proposed treatment and the long-term compliance of patients treated in a specialist periodontal office in Norway. This was part of an internal quality control measure for this practice.
152 consecutive patients who completed periodontal therapy in 1988 were retrospectively assessed after 10 years. In addition, the case records of 624 consecutive patients referred for periodontal assessment between 1989 and 1993 were examined to determine how many decided to accept the proposed therapy.
The majority 132 (87%) of those who completed treatment in 1988 had attended for the prescribed maintenance therapy over a ten-year period. It was not possible to detect any differences between the compliers and non-compliers in terms of age, gender, severity of disease, cost and national insurance coverage. The 152 patients were originally referred by 18 general dental practitioners. The 'high referring' dentists (>8 referrals) had significantly more non-complying patients than dentists who made less than 7 referrals. 20 (3%) of the 624 periodontal referrals over a 5-year period chose not to proceed with the proposed therapy.
There was a high level of patient compliance in the population group studied in this specialist periodontal practice. Geographic and cultural factors as well as a stable rural population may be important factors in the high level of compliance with maintenance therapy in this practice. The referring general dental practitioners may also play an important role in patient compliance.
患者对牙周维护治疗的依从性对治疗效果很重要,然而,大多数研究报告的依从率仅在11% - 45%之间。本研究的目的是报告挪威一家专科牙周诊所患者对所提议治疗的接受情况以及长期依从性。这是该诊所内部质量控制措施的一部分。
对1988年完成牙周治疗的152例连续患者进行了10年后的回顾性评估。此外,检查了1989年至1993年间624例连续转诊进行牙周评估的患者的病历,以确定有多少人决定接受所提议的治疗。
1988年完成治疗的患者中,大多数132例(87%)在十年期间接受了规定的维护治疗。在依从者和不依从者之间,在年龄、性别、疾病严重程度、费用和国家保险覆盖方面未发现任何差异。这152例患者最初由18名普通牙科医生转诊。“高转诊量”的牙医(>8次转诊)的不依从患者明显多于转诊次数少于7次的牙医。在5年期间的624例牙周转诊患者中,20例(3%)选择不进行所提议的治疗。
在这家专科牙周诊所所研究的人群组中,患者依从性较高。地理和文化因素以及稳定的农村人口可能是该诊所维护治疗依从性高的重要因素。转诊的普通牙科医生在患者依从性方面也可能发挥重要作用。