Hastie Barbara A, Riley Joseph L, Fillingim Roger B
University of Florida College of Dentistry, Division of Public Health Services and Research, Gainesville, Florida 32610, USA.
Pain Med. 2005 Jan-Feb;6(1):61-71. doi: 10.1111/j.1526-4637.2005.05009.x.
Ethnic disparities in pain have recently gained increasing attention; however, relatively few studies have examined ethnic differences in pain prevalence, and even fewer have addressed whether ethnic groups differ in their pain-reducing behaviors. Thus, this study investigated ethnic differences in pain prevalence and impact among healthy young African Americans, Hispanics, and non-Hispanic whites.(1) Also, ethnic differences in pain-reducing behaviors were explored. Undergraduate students (N = 1,037) from three ethnic groups completed a telephone survey of recent pain experiences. Groups did not differ in overall pain frequency or severity; however, more African Americans reported chest and stomach region pain, whereas more Hispanics reported pain in the legs/feet. Significant group differences regarding pain-reducing behaviors emerged. More whites utilized self-care behaviors, compared to Hispanics and African Americans. Conversely, greater numbers of African Americans and Hispanics than whites reported having prayed to relieve pain. The predictors of the total number of pain-reducing behaviors used differed across ethnic groups. For whites, pain intensity and interference were the strongest predictors of pain-reducing behaviors. For African Americans, total pain sites, as well as interference and frustration, were significantly associated with pain-reducing behaviors, while among Hispanics, worry and frustration were the strongest predictors for total pain-reducing behaviors. These results suggest potentially important ethnic differences in patterns and predictors of pain-reducing actions, and their emergence in a healthy sample suggest that ethnic differences in pain-related responses predate the development of chronic pain. These findings may have important implications for understanding ethnic differences in responses to clinical pain and for tailoring treatment approaches to eliminate disparities.
疼痛方面的种族差异最近越来越受到关注;然而,相对较少的研究考察了疼痛患病率的种族差异,甚至更少的研究探讨了不同种族在减轻疼痛行为上是否存在差异。因此,本研究调查了健康的年轻非裔美国人、西班牙裔和非西班牙裔白人在疼痛患病率及影响方面的种族差异。(1)此外,还探讨了减轻疼痛行为的种族差异。来自三个种族的本科生(N = 1037)完成了一项关于近期疼痛经历的电话调查。各群体在总体疼痛频率或严重程度上没有差异;然而,更多非裔美国人报告胸部和胃部区域疼痛,而更多西班牙裔报告腿部/脚部疼痛。在减轻疼痛行为方面出现了显著的群体差异。与西班牙裔和非裔美国人相比,更多白人采用自我护理行为。相反,报告通过祈祷来减轻疼痛的非裔美国人和西班牙裔人数多于白人。不同种族使用的减轻疼痛行为总数的预测因素也不同。对于白人,疼痛强度和干扰是减轻疼痛行为的最强预测因素。对于非裔美国人,疼痛部位总数以及干扰和沮丧与减轻疼痛行为显著相关,而在西班牙裔中,担忧和沮丧是减轻疼痛行为总数的最强预测因素。这些结果表明,在减轻疼痛行为的模式和预测因素方面可能存在重要的种族差异,并且这些差异在健康样本中的出现表明,与疼痛相关的反应的种族差异在慢性疼痛发展之前就已存在。这些发现可能对理解临床疼痛反应中的种族差异以及为消除差异而调整治疗方法具有重要意义。