Gennarelli Melissa, Jandorf Lina, Cromwell Caroline, Valdimarsdottir Heiddis, Redd William, Itzkowitz Steven
Derald H. Ruttenberg Cancer Center, Mount Sinai School of Medicine, One East 100th Street, New York, NY 10029, USA.
Mt Sinai J Med. 2005 Jan;72(1):36-44.
The rate of colorectal cancer (CRC) screening remains relatively low. One potential barrier to higher rates is the lack of physician knowledge regarding CRC screening. The purpose of this study was to assess physicians' knowledge of (a) American Cancer Society (ACS) CRC screening guidelines for average-risk and high-risk patients, and (b) general colorectal cancer facts which support these guidelines.
We administered a questionnaire to internal medicine residents, internal medicine attendings and medical students who provide care to patients in a low-income, predominantly minority community, to compare their levels of knowledge regarding CRC screening. Mean knowledge scores were calculated based on the number of correct responses.
Knowledge of ACS guidelines for average-risk patients was low, although it did increase directly with level of training: medical students obtained a mean score of 32%, residents 49%, and attendings 56% (p<0.001). Knowledge scores for high-risk patients were even lower, with fewer than half of the respondents offering correct answers. Mean knowledge scores of general CRC screening facts increased with level of training: medical students scored 31%, residents 38% and attendings 42% (p<0.001).
Knowledge of CRC screening guidelines for both average- and high-risk patients was suboptimal among the medical students, residents and attendings studied. Lack of knowledge about CRC is one barrier to screening that may contribute to underutilization of screening for minority populations. Further educational efforts should be targeted to these health care professionals.
结直肠癌(CRC)筛查率仍然相对较低。筛查率提高的一个潜在障碍是医生缺乏关于CRC筛查的知识。本研究的目的是评估医生对以下方面的了解:(a)美国癌症协会(ACS)针对平均风险和高风险患者的CRC筛查指南,以及(b)支持这些指南的一般结直肠癌相关事实。
我们向在内科住院医师、内科主治医师以及在低收入、以少数族裔为主的社区为患者提供护理的医学生发放了问卷,以比较他们关于CRC筛查的知识水平。根据正确回答的数量计算平均知识得分。
对ACS平均风险患者指南的了解程度较低,尽管其确实随培训水平直接提高:医学生的平均得分为32%,住院医师为49%,主治医师为56%(p<0.001)。对高风险患者的知识得分甚至更低,不到一半的受访者给出了正确答案。关于一般CRC筛查事实的平均知识得分随培训水平提高:医学生得分为31%,住院医师为38%,主治医师为42%(p<0.001)。
在所研究的医学生、住院医师和主治医师中,对平均风险和高风险患者的CRC筛查指南的了解都不理想。对CRC缺乏了解是筛查的一个障碍,可能导致少数族裔人群筛查利用不足。应针对这些医疗保健专业人员开展进一步的教育工作。