Slotnick Scott D, Thompson William L, Kosslyn Stephen M
Department of Psychology, Boston College, McGuinn Hall, Chestnut Hill, MA 02467, USA.
Cereb Cortex. 2005 Oct;15(10):1570-83. doi: 10.1093/cercor/bhi035. Epub 2005 Feb 2.
There is a long-standing debate as to whether visual mental imagery relies entirely on symbolic (language-like) representations or also relies on depictive (picture-like) representations. We sought to discover whether visual mental imagery could evoke cortical activity with precise visual field topography (retinotopy). Participants received three conditions: the perception condition consisted of a standard retinotopic mapping procedure, where two flickering checkerboard wedges rotated around a central fixation point. The imagery and attention conditions consisted of the same stimulus, but only the outer arcs of the wedges were visible. During imagery, participants mentally reproduced the stimulus wedges, using the stimulus arcs as a guide. The attention condition required either distributed attention or focused attention to where the stimulus wedges would have been. Event-related analysis revealed that the imagery (greater than either form of attention) retinotopic maps were similar to the perception maps. Moreover, blocked analysis revealed similar perception and imagery effects in human motion processing region MT+. These results support the depictive view of visual mental imagery.
关于视觉心理意象是完全依赖于符号(类似语言)表征还是也依赖于描绘(类似图片)表征,一直存在着长期的争论。我们试图探究视觉心理意象是否能引发具有精确视野拓扑结构(视网膜拓扑结构)的皮层活动。参与者接受了三种条件:感知条件包括一个标准的视网膜拓扑映射程序,其中两个闪烁的棋盘格楔形围绕一个中央注视点旋转。意象和注意力条件包括相同的刺激,但只有楔形的外弧可见。在意象过程中,参与者以刺激弧为引导,在脑海中重现刺激楔形。注意力条件要求对刺激楔形原本所在位置进行分散注意力或集中注意力。事件相关分析表明,意象(大于任何一种注意力形式)的视网膜拓扑图与感知图相似。此外,分组分析揭示了在人类运动处理区域MT+中类似的感知和意象效应。这些结果支持了视觉心理意象的描绘观点。