Held Leonhard, Natário Isabel, Fenton Sarah Elaine, Rue Håvard, Becker Nikolaus
Department of Statistics, University of Munich, Germany,
Stat Methods Med Res. 2005 Feb;14(1):61-82. doi: 10.1191/0962280205sm389oa.
This article discusses and extends statistical models to jointly analyse the spatial variation of rates of several diseases with common risk factors. We start with a review of methods for separate analyses of diseases, then move to ecological regression approaches, where the rates from one of the diseases enter as surrogate covariates for exposure. Finally, we propose a general framework for jointly modelling the variation of two or more diseases, some of which share latent spatial fields, but with possibly different risk gradients. In our application, we consider mortality data on oral, oesophagus, larynx and lung cancers for males in Germany, which all share smoking as a common risk factor. Furthermore, the first three cancers are also known to be related to excessive alcohol consumption. An empirical comparison of the different models based on a formal model criterion as well as on the posterior precision of the relative risk estimates strongly suggests that the joint modelling approach is a useful and valuable extension over individual analyses.
本文讨论并扩展了统计模型,以联合分析几种具有共同风险因素的疾病发病率的空间变化。我们首先回顾了对疾病进行单独分析的方法,然后转向生态回归方法,其中一种疾病的发病率作为暴露的替代协变量纳入分析。最后,我们提出了一个通用框架,用于联合建模两种或更多种疾病的变化,其中一些疾病共享潜在的空间场,但可能具有不同的风险梯度。在我们的应用中,我们考虑了德国男性口腔癌、食管癌、喉癌和肺癌的死亡率数据,这些癌症都以吸烟作为共同的风险因素。此外,已知前三种癌症还与过量饮酒有关。基于正式模型标准以及相对风险估计的后验精度对不同模型进行的实证比较有力地表明,联合建模方法是对单独分析的一种有用且有价值的扩展。