Law Jane, Abdullah Abu Yousuf Md
School of Planning, University of Waterloo, 200 University Avenue West, Waterloo, ON N2L 3G1 Canada.
School of Public Health Sciences, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON Canada.
J Quant Criminol. 2024;40(1):75-98. doi: 10.1007/s10940-022-09562-9. Epub 2022 Nov 5.
We attempted to apply the Bayesian shared component spatial modeling (SCSM) for the identification of hotspots from two (offenders and offenses) instead of one (offenders or offenses) variables and developed three risk surfaces for (1) common or shared by both offenders and offenses; (2) specific to offenders, and (3) specific to offenses.
We applied SCSM to examine the joint spatial distributions of juvenile delinquents (offenders) and violent crime (offenses) in the York Region of the Greater Toronto Area at the dissemination area level. The spatial autocorrelation, overdispersion, and latent covariates were adjusted by spatially structured and unstructured random effect terms in the model. We mapped the posterior means of the estimated shared and specific risks for identifying the three risk surfaces and types of hotspots.
Results suggest that about 50% and 25% of the relative risks of juvenile delinquents and violent crimes, respectively, could be explained by the shared component of offenders and offenses. The spatially structured terms attributed to 48% and 24% of total variations of the delinquents and violent crimes, respectively. Contrastingly, the unstructured random covariates influenced 3% of total variations of the juvenile delinquents and 51% for violent crimes.
The Bayesian SCSM presented in this study identifies shared and specific hotspots of juvenile delinquents and violent crime. The method can be applied to other kinds of offenders and offenses and provide new insights into the clusters of high risks that are due to both offenders and offenses or due to offenders or offenses only.
我们尝试应用贝叶斯共享成分空间建模(SCSM)从两个变量(犯罪者和犯罪行为)而非一个变量(犯罪者或犯罪行为)中识别热点,并为以下三个方面生成风险曲面:(1)犯罪者和犯罪行为共同的或共享的;(2)特定于犯罪者的;(3)特定于犯罪行为的。
我们应用SCSM在传播区域层面研究大多伦多地区约克区青少年犯罪者(犯罪者)和暴力犯罪(犯罪行为)的联合空间分布。模型中通过空间结构化和非结构化随机效应项调整空间自相关、过度分散和潜在协变量。我们绘制估计的共享和特定风险的后验均值,以识别三个风险曲面和热点类型。
结果表明,青少年犯罪者和暴力犯罪的相对风险分别约有50%和25%可由犯罪者和犯罪行为的共享成分解释。空间结构化项分别占犯罪者和暴力犯罪总变异的48%和24%。相反,非结构化随机协变量对青少年犯罪者总变异的影响为3%,对暴力犯罪的影响为51%。
本研究中提出的贝叶斯SCSM识别了青少年犯罪者和暴力犯罪的共享和特定热点。该方法可应用于其他类型的犯罪者和犯罪行为,并为因犯罪者和犯罪行为共同导致或仅因犯罪者或犯罪行为导致的高风险集群提供新的见解。