De Vries Jean-Paul P M, Jager L Cara, Van den Berg Jos C, Overtoom Tim Th C, Ackerstaff Rob G A, Van de Pavoordt Eric D W M, Moll Frans L
Department of Vascular Surgery, St Antonius Hospital, Koekoekslaan 1, 3435 CM, Nieuwegein, The Netherlands.
J Vasc Surg. 2005 Jan;41(1):19-23. doi: 10.1016/j.jvs.2004.09.030.
Percutaneous transluminal angioplasty (PTA) is one of the treatment options for localized obstruction of the subclavian artery. To document long-term durability of this kind of PTA we report a 10-year single-center experience in 110 patients.
From January 1993 to July 2003, 110 patients (72 women; mean age, 62 +/- 10 years) underwent PTA of symptomatic (>75%) stenosis (n = 90) or occlusion of the proximal subclavian artery (84 left-sided). Forty one patients (37%) had symptoms of vertebrobasilar insufficiency, 29 patients (26%) had disabling chronic arm ischemia, and 20 patients had both symptoms. Twenty patients with coronary artery disease underwent PTA in preparation for myocardial revascularization with the internal mammary artery. Duplex scans and arteriograms confirmed significant stenosis or occlusion. All PTA procedures were performed with the patient under local anesthesia, through the femoral artery (n = 89), brachial artery (n = 6), or combined route (n = 15). In 59 patients (58%) an additional stent was placed.
Angioplasty was initially technically and clinically successful in 102 patients (93%). Seven occlusions could not be recanalized, and 1 procedure had to be stopped because of ischemic stroke. Of the 102 patients in whom treatment was successful, 1 patient (1%) had a minor stroke in the contralateral hemisphere 2 hours post-PTA. Seven patients (7%) had minor problems, all without permanent sequelae. Follow-up with duplex scanning ranged from 3 months to 10 years (mean, 34 months). Primary clinical patency at 5 years was 89%, with a median recurrent obstruction-free period of 23 months. The local complication rate was 4.5%, and the combined stroke and death rate was 3.6%. Significant recurrent obstruction (>70%) developed in 8 patients with clinical symptoms. Four stenoses were successfully treated with repeat PTA (2 with additional stent placement); 4occlusions required surgery.
PTA of obstructive lesions of the proximal subclavian artery is not only an effective initial treatment, but is also successful over the long-term. Inasmuch as all clinical failures occured within 26 months after initial therapy, we recommend regular follow-up for at least 2 years post-PTA. All clinically significant recurrent stenoses can be treated with repeat endovascular procedures. We could not prove positive or negative influence of additional placement of stents; however, the number of recurrent stenoses might be too small in this retrospective study to draw firm conclusions. Adverse events of any kind are certainly no greater than with invasive surgical procedures. Therefore PTA must be seriously considered in patients with localized obstruction of the proximal subclavian artery.
经皮腔内血管成形术(PTA)是锁骨下动脉局限性阻塞的治疗选择之一。为记录此类PTA的长期疗效,我们报告了在一家中心对110例患者进行的为期10年的经验。
1993年1月至2003年7月,110例患者(72例女性;平均年龄62±10岁)接受了有症状(>75%)狭窄(n = 90)或近端锁骨下动脉闭塞(84例左侧)的PTA治疗。41例患者(37%)有椎基底动脉供血不足症状,29例患者(26%)有导致功能障碍的慢性手臂缺血,20例患者同时有这两种症状。20例冠心病患者为准备用乳内动脉进行心肌血运重建而接受PTA治疗。双功扫描和血管造影证实有明显狭窄或闭塞。所有PTA手术均在患者局部麻醉下,经股动脉(n = 89)、肱动脉(n = 6)或联合途径(n = 15)进行。59例患者(58%)额外置入了支架。
血管成形术最初在技术和临床方面对102例患者(93%)成功。7例闭塞未能再通,1例手术因缺血性卒中而中止。在治疗成功的102例患者中,1例患者(1%)在PTA后2小时对侧半球发生轻度卒中。7例患者(7%)有轻微问题,均无永久性后遗症。双功扫描随访时间为3个月至10年(平均34个月)。5年时的主要临床通畅率为89%,复发无阻塞期的中位数为23个月。局部并发症发生率为4.5%,卒中与死亡率之和为3.6%。8例有临床症状的患者出现明显的复发阻塞(>70%)。4例狭窄经重复PTA成功治疗(2例额外置入了支架);4例闭塞需要手术治疗。
近端锁骨下动脉阻塞性病变的PTA不仅是一种有效的初始治疗方法,而且长期效果也良好。由于所有临床失败均发生在初始治疗后的26个月内,我们建议PTA后至少定期随访2年。所有具有临床意义的复发狭窄均可通过重复血管内手术治疗。我们无法证明额外置入支架的正负影响;然而,在这项回顾性研究中,复发狭窄的数量可能太少以至于无法得出确切结论。任何类型的不良事件肯定不超过侵入性外科手术。因此,对于近端锁骨下动脉局限性阻塞的患者,必须认真考虑PTA治疗。