Banasiak Nancy Cantey, Meadows-Oliver Mikki
Yale University School of Nursing, New Haven, CT, USA.
Pediatr Nurs. 2004 Nov-Dec;30(6):447-50.
Asthma is one of the most prevalent childhood chronic illnesses in the United States leading to nearly 190,000 pediatric hospitalizations yearly. In response to the increasing number of children with asthma being hospitalized, some institutions have developed and implemented clinical pathways and are now reporting their findings in the literature. The purpose of this paper was to conduct an integrative literature review of studies using an inpatient clinical pathway for the management of pediatric asthma.
Five research-based articles evaluating clinical pathways for the management of inpatient pediatric asthma were included in this review. The integrative review was conducted using the guidelines set forth by Ganong (1987).
The results revealed that clinical pathways appear to be effective in reducing length of stay and hospital costs associated with inpatient pediatric asthma. The pathways were not as effective in reducing readmission rates or affecting clinical outcomes for patients such as increasing asthma education, the use of controller medications, spacers, and peak flow meters.
Although the pathways are effective in reducing hospitalization costs associated with asthma, there was little reported improvement in clinical outcomes. Nurses should ensure that each pediatric asthma hospitalization provides an opportunity to promote education about asthma. This approach may lead to decreased asthma admissions and increased self and family management of pediatric asthma. Future research should focus on the clinical outcomes of patients using the inpatient pathways and also on the development of pathways to be used in outpatient settings that manage pediatric asthma.
哮喘是美国最常见的儿童慢性疾病之一,每年导致近19万名儿童住院。为应对哮喘住院儿童数量的增加,一些机构制定并实施了临床路径,目前正在文献中报告其研究结果。本文的目的是对使用住院临床路径管理儿童哮喘的研究进行综合文献综述。
本综述纳入了五篇基于研究的评估住院儿童哮喘管理临床路径的文章。综合综述按照加农(1987年)提出的指南进行。
结果显示,临床路径似乎在缩短住院时间和降低与住院儿童哮喘相关的医院成本方面有效。这些路径在降低再入院率或影响患者临床结局方面效果不佳,如增加哮喘教育、使用控制药物、储雾罐和峰流速仪。
尽管这些路径在降低与哮喘相关的住院成本方面有效,但临床结局方面几乎没有报告显示有改善。护士应确保每次儿童哮喘住院都提供促进哮喘教育的机会。这种方法可能会减少哮喘住院次数,并增强儿童哮喘的自我管理和家庭管理。未来的研究应关注使用住院路径的患者的临床结局,以及开发用于管理儿童哮喘门诊环境的路径。