Cagici Can Alper, Cakmak Ozcan, Hurcan Cem, Tercan Fahri
Department of ENT, Baskent University Faculty of Medicine, Adana Teaching and Medical Research Center, Baraj Yolu 1 Durak, Seyhan, Adana, Turkey.
Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 2005 Sep;262(9):744-50. doi: 10.1007/s00405-004-0896-8. Epub 2005 Feb 26.
Plain sinus radiography is the imaging technique most frequently used to investigate suspected rhinosinusitis, but it has low diagnostic sensitivity. Contiguous paranasal computerized tomography (CT) gives detailed information about the pathology, anatomy and anatomical variations of the paranasal sinuses, but this method also has limitations. The cost of using this technique for all cases of suspected rhinosinusitis is prohibitive, and complete CT scans involve considerable radiation exposure. The aim of this study was to devise a CT protocol for diagnosing and following rhinosinusitis that is more economical and involves much less radiation exposure than contiguous CT. In this retrospective study, three physicians independently reviewed the contiguous coronal paranasal CT studies of 136 patients. The study population comprised the adult patients who were investigated for suspected chronic rhinosinusitis. All scans had been obtained at the second visit, after the patient had completed a 3-week course of medical treatment. For each case, the same three slices were selected to form the "three-slice CT" exam, and the same physicians independently evaluated this set. Using the results from the contiguous set as the gold standard, we calculated the sensitivity and specificity of three-slice CT for identifying rhinosinusitis. The sensitivity and specificity of three-slice CT for identifying inflammatory sinus disease were 95.1 and 92.6%, respectively. Three-slice CT is a valuable method for diagnosing and following rhinosinusitis cases, and would be cheaper and involve less radiation exposure than contiguous coronal CT. However, despite the high cost and greater radiation exposure, contiguous CT remains the gold standard for evaluating detailed sinus anatomy and disease progression.
鼻窦平片是用于检查疑似鼻窦炎最常用的成像技术,但它的诊断敏感性较低。鼻窦计算机断层扫描(CT)能提供有关鼻窦病理、解剖结构及解剖变异的详细信息,但该方法也存在局限性。对所有疑似鼻窦炎病例都使用这种技术的成本过高,而且完整的CT扫描会带来相当大的辐射暴露。本研究的目的是设计一种用于诊断和跟踪鼻窦炎的CT方案,该方案比连续CT更经济且辐射暴露少得多。在这项回顾性研究中,三位医生独立审查了136例患者的鼻窦连续冠状位CT研究。研究对象为因疑似慢性鼻窦炎接受检查的成年患者。所有扫描均在患者完成3周药物治疗后的第二次就诊时进行。对于每个病例,选择相同的三个层面组成“三层CT”检查,由相同的医生独立评估这组图像。以连续扫描的结果作为金标准,我们计算了三层CT诊断鼻窦炎的敏感性和特异性。三层CT诊断炎症性鼻窦疾病的敏感性和特异性分别为95.1%和92.6%。三层CT是诊断和跟踪鼻窦炎病例的一种有价值的方法,比连续冠状位CT更便宜且辐射暴露更少。然而,尽管成本高且辐射暴露大,连续CT仍然是评估鼻窦详细解剖结构和疾病进展的金标准。