Teucher Birgit, Olivares Manuel, Cori Héctor
Nutrition Division, Institute of Food Research, Norwich NR4 7UA, UK.
Int J Vitam Nutr Res. 2004 Nov;74(6):403-19. doi: 10.1024/0300-9831.74.6.403.
Ascorbic acid (AA), with its reducing and chelating properties, is the most efficient enhancer of non-heme iron absorption when its stability in the food vehicle is ensured. The number of studies investigating the effect of AA on ferrous sulfate absorption far outweighs that of other iron fortificants. The promotion of iron absorption in the presence of AA is more pronounced in meals containing inhibitors of iron absorption. Meals containing low to medium levels of inhibitors require the addition of AA at a molar ratio of 2:1 (e.g., 20 mg AA: 3 mg iron). To promote absorption in the presence of high levels of inhibitors, AA needs to be added at a molar ratio in excess of 4:1, which may be impractical. The effectiveness of AA in promoting absorption from less soluble compounds, such as ferrous fumarate and elemental iron, requires further investigation. The instability of AA during food processing, storage, and cooking, and the possibility of unwanted sensory changes limits the number of suitable food vehicles for AA, whether used as vitamin fortificant or as an iron enhancer. Suitable vehicles include dry-blended foods, such as complementary, precooked cereal-based infant foods, powdered milk, and other dry beverage products made for reconstitution that are packaged, stored, and prepared in a way that maximizes retention of this vitamin. The consumption of natural sources of Vitamin C (fruits and vegetables) with iron-fortified dry blended foods is also recommended. Encapsulation can mitigate some of the AA losses during processing and storage, but these interventions will also add cost. In addition, the bioavailability of encapsulated iron in the presence/absence of AA will need careful assessment in human clinical trials. The long-term effect of high AA intake on iron status may be less than predicted from single meal studies. The hypothesis that an overall increase of dietary AA intake, or fortification of some foods commonly consumed with the main meal with AA alone, may be as effective as the fortification of the same food vehicle with AA and iron, merits further investigation. This must involve the consideration of practicalities of implementation. To date, programs based on iron and AA fortification of infant formulas and cow's milk provide the strongest evidence for the efficacy of AA fortification. Present results suggest that the effect of organic acids, as measured by in vitro and in vivo methods, is dependent on the source of iron, the type and concentration of organic acid, pH, processing methods, and the food matrix. The iron absorption-enhancing effect of AA is more potent than that of other organic acids due to its ability to reduce ferric to ferrous iron. Based on the limited data available, other organic acids may only be effective at ratios of acid to iron in excess of 100 molar. This would translate into the minimum presence/addition of 1 g citric acid to a meal containing 3 mg iron. Further characterization of the effectiveness of various organic acids in promoting iron absorption is required, in particular with respect to the optimal molar ratio of organic acid to iron, and associated feasibility for food application purposes. The suggested amount of any organic acid required to produce a nutritional benefit will result in unwanted organoleptic changes in most foods, thus limiting its application to a small number of food vehicles (e.g., condiments, beverages). However, fermented foods that already contain high levels of organic acid may be suitable iron fortification vehicles.
抗坏血酸(AA)具有还原和螯合特性,当其在食品载体中的稳定性得到保证时,是促进非血红素铁吸收最有效的增强剂。研究AA对硫酸亚铁吸收影响的研究数量远远超过其他铁强化剂。在含有铁吸收抑制剂的膳食中,AA对铁吸收的促进作用更为明显。含有低至中等水平抑制剂的膳食需要以2:1的摩尔比添加AA(例如,20毫克AA:3毫克铁)。为了在高水平抑制剂存在的情况下促进吸收,需要以超过4:1的摩尔比添加AA,这可能不切实际。AA促进从较难溶解的化合物(如富马酸亚铁和元素铁)中吸收的有效性需要进一步研究。AA在食品加工、储存和烹饪过程中的不稳定性,以及产生不良感官变化的可能性,限制了适合添加AA的食品载体数量,无论AA是用作维生素强化剂还是铁增强剂。合适的载体包括干混食品,如补充性的、预煮的谷物基婴儿食品、奶粉以及其他用于复水的干饮料产品,它们的包装、储存和制备方式能最大程度地保留这种维生素。也建议将富含维生素C的天然来源(水果和蔬菜)与铁强化干混食品一起食用。包囊可以减轻加工和储存过程中AA的一些损失,但这些干预措施也会增加成本。此外,在人体临床试验中需要仔细评估包囊铁在有无AA情况下的生物利用度。高剂量AA摄入对铁状态的长期影响可能小于单次膳食研究的预测。膳食中AA摄入量总体增加,或者仅在与主餐一起食用的某些常见食物中强化AA,可能与在同一食品载体中同时强化AA和铁一样有效,这一假设值得进一步研究。这必须考虑实施的实际情况。迄今为止,基于婴儿配方奶粉和牛奶中铁和AA强化的项目为AA强化的功效提供了最有力的证据。目前的结果表明,通过体外和体内方法测量的有机酸的效果取决于铁源、有机酸的类型和浓度、pH值、加工方法以及食物基质。由于AA能够将三价铁还原为二价铁,其促进铁吸收的效果比其他有机酸更强。根据现有有限的数据,其他有机酸可能仅在酸与铁的摩尔比超过100时才有效。这意味着在含有3毫克铁的一餐中至少要添加1克柠檬酸。需要进一步表征各种有机酸促进铁吸收的有效性,特别是关于有机酸与铁的最佳摩尔比以及在食品应用方面的相关可行性。为产生营养益处所需的任何有机酸建议用量会在大多数食物中导致不良的感官变化,因此将其应用限制在少数食品载体(如调味品、饮料)中。然而,已经含有高水平有机酸的发酵食品可能是合适的铁强化载体。