Blakely Tony, Hales Simon, Kieft Charlotte, Wilson Nick, Woodward Alistair
Department of Public Health, Wellington School of Medicine and Health Sciences, University of Otago, Wellington, New Zealand.
Bull World Health Organ. 2005 Feb;83(2):118-26. Epub 2005 Feb 24.
To estimate the individual-level association of income poverty with being underweight, using tobacco, drinking alcohol, having access only to unsafe water and sanitation, being exposed to indoor air pollution and being obese.
Using survey data for as many countries as possible, we estimated the relative risk association between income or assets and risk factors at the individual level within 11 medium- and low-income subregions of WHO. WHO and The World Bank data on the prevalence of risk factors and income poverty (defined as living on < US$ 1.00 per day, US$ 1-2.00 per day and > US$ 2.00 per day) were analysed to impute the association between poverty and risk factors for each subregion. The possible effect of poverty reduction on the prevalence of risk factors was estimated using population-attributable risk percentages.
There were strong associations between poverty and malnutrition among children, having access only to unsafe water and sanitation, and being exposed to indoor air pollution within each subregion (relative risks were twofold to threefold greater for those living on < US$ 1.00 per day compared with those living on > US$ 2.00 per day). Associations between poverty and obesity, tobacco use and alcohol use varied across subregions. If everyone living on < US$ 2.00 per day had the risk factor profile of those living on > US$ 2.00 per day, 51% of exposures to unimproved water and sanitation could be avoided as could 37% of malnutrition among children and 38% of exposure to indoor air pollution. The more realistic, but still challenging, Millennium Development Goal of halving the number of people living on < US$ 1.00 per day would achieve much smaller reductions.
To achieve large gains in global health requires both poverty eradication and public health action. The methods used in this study may be useful for monitoring pro-equity progress towards Millennium Development Goals.
评估收入贫困与体重不足、吸烟、饮酒、仅能获取不安全饮用水和卫生设施、暴露于室内空气污染以及肥胖之间的个体层面关联。
利用尽可能多国家的调查数据,我们在世卫组织11个中低收入次区域内估计了个体层面收入或资产与风险因素之间的相对风险关联。分析了世卫组织和世界银行关于风险因素患病率及收入贫困(定义为每日生活费低于1.00美元、1 - 2.00美元以及高于2.00美元)的数据,以推算每个次区域贫困与风险因素之间的关联。使用人群归因风险百分比估计了减贫对风险因素患病率的可能影响。
各次区域内贫困与儿童营养不良、仅能获取不安全饮用水和卫生设施以及暴露于室内空气污染之间存在密切关联(与每日生活费高于2.00美元的人群相比,每日生活费低于1.00美元的人群相对风险高出两倍至三倍)。贫困与肥胖、吸烟和饮酒之间的关联在不同次区域有所不同。如果所有每日生活费低于2.00美元的人都具有每日生活费高于2.00美元人群的风险因素特征,那么51%的不安全饮用水和卫生设施暴露、37%的儿童营养不良以及38%的室内空气污染暴露都可避免。将每日生活费低于1.00美元的人数减半这一虽更现实但仍具挑战性的千年发展目标,所实现的减少幅度要小得多。
要在全球健康方面取得巨大进展,既需要消除贫困,也需要采取公共卫生行动。本研究中使用的方法可能有助于监测实现千年发展目标的公平进展情况。