Bradley Cathy J, Gardiner Joseph, Given Charles W, Roberts Caralee
Department of Health Administration, Virginia Commonwealth University, Richmond, Virginia 23298, USA.
Cancer. 2005 Apr 15;103(8):1712-8. doi: 10.1002/cncr.20954.
The current article examined survival for adults < 65 years old diagnosed with breast, colorectal, or lung carcinoma who were either Medicaid insured at the time of diagnosis, Medicaid insured after diagnosis, or non-Medicaid insured.
The authors hypothesized that subjects enrolling in Medicaid after they were diagnosed with cancer would explain disparate survival outcomes between Medicaid and non-Medicaid-insured subjects. The authors used the Michigan Tumor Registry, a population-based cancer registry covering the State of Michigan, to identify subjects who were diagnosed with the cancer sites of interest (n = 13,740). The primary outcome was all cause mortality over an 8-year time period.
Subjects who enrolled in Medicaid after diagnosis with cancer had much lower 8-year survival rates relative to Medicaid-enrolled and non-Medicaid subjects. These reductions in survival were partly due to a high proportion of lung carcinoma and late-stage cancers within the sample of subjects who enrolled in Medicaid after diagnosis. The likelihood of death was two to three times greater for subjects enrolled in Medicaid relative to subjects who were not enrolled in Medicaid once the analysis was stratified by cancer site and stage.
Disparities in cancer survival were apparent between subjects enrolled in Medicaid and subjects not enrolled in Medicaid. From a policy perspective, cancer survival in the Medicaid population cannot be improved as long as 40% of the population enrolls in Medicaid after diagnosis with late-stage disease.
本文研究了年龄小于65岁、被诊断患有乳腺癌、结直肠癌或肺癌的成年人的生存率,这些患者在诊断时参加医疗补助计划、诊断后参加医疗补助计划或未参加医疗补助计划。
作者假设,癌症诊断后参加医疗补助计划的受试者可以解释医疗补助计划参保者与未参保者之间不同的生存结果。作者使用密歇根肿瘤登记处(一个覆盖密歇根州的基于人群的癌症登记处)来识别被诊断患有感兴趣癌症部位的受试者(n = 13740)。主要结局是8年期间的全因死亡率。
癌症诊断后参加医疗补助计划的受试者的8年生存率相对于参加医疗补助计划和未参加医疗补助计划的受试者要低得多。这些生存率的降低部分归因于诊断后参加医疗补助计划的受试者样本中肺癌和晚期癌症的比例较高。一旦按癌症部位和阶段进行分层分析,参加医疗补助计划的受试者的死亡可能性是未参加医疗补助计划的受试者的两到三倍。
参加医疗补助计划的受试者与未参加医疗补助计划的受试者之间在癌症生存率方面存在明显差异。从政策角度来看,只要40%的人群在被诊断患有晚期疾病后参加医疗补助计划,医疗补助计划人群的癌症生存率就无法提高。