Berg Janna, Aase Steinar, Søland Torunn Helene, Gabrielsen Anne Marie, Svendsen Martin Veel, Lien Jan Thomas, Hauss Gerhardt
Department of Internal Medicine, Telemark Public Hospital, Skien, Norway.
APMIS. 2005 Mar;113(3):208-12. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0463.2005.apm1130309.x.
In order to elucidate the relative contributions made by cytology and histology in the diagnosis of lung cancer, we studied the cytology and histology reports of all patients who received a microscopic diagnosis of lung cancer in our hospital during the 7 years 1996-2002. This gave a total of 407 patients. The most frequent diagnoses were squamous cell carcinoma (34.9%), adenocarcinoma (24.8%), and small cell carcinoma (17.8%). One hundred and fifteen patients (28.3%) received their microscopic diagnosis based only on cytology, which therefore proved to be of great diagnostic value. The most useful type of cytology specimen was taken by bronchial lavage or bronchial brushing. These types of specimens provided the diagnosis in 71 patients (17.4%). Cytology was especially capable of finding squamous cell carcinomas. Small cell carcinomas were underrepresented (9.6% versus 17.8%) and unspecified carcinomas greatly overrepresented (9.6% versus 2.9%) among the diagnoses obtained by cytology alone. We conclude that cytology is of considerable diagnostic value, although not as specific as histology for the subtyping of carcinomas. Clinicians should be more aware of the usefulness of cytology, especially in cases where it is difficult to obtain bronchoscopic biopsy samples for histological examination.
为了阐明细胞学和组织学在肺癌诊断中的相对贡献,我们研究了1996年至2002年这7年间在我院接受肺癌显微镜诊断的所有患者的细胞学和组织学报告。共有407例患者。最常见的诊断是鳞状细胞癌(34.9%)、腺癌(24.8%)和小细胞癌(17.8%)。115例患者(28.3%)仅根据细胞学获得显微镜诊断,因此证明细胞学具有很大的诊断价值。最有用的细胞学标本类型是通过支气管灌洗或支气管刷检获取的。这些标本类型为71例患者(17.4%)提供了诊断。细胞学尤其能够发现鳞状细胞癌。在仅通过细胞学获得的诊断中,小细胞癌的比例偏低(9.6%对17.8%),未明确类型的癌比例偏高(9.6%对2.9%)。我们得出结论,细胞学具有相当大的诊断价值,尽管对于癌的亚型分类不如组织学特异。临床医生应更加意识到细胞学的有用性,尤其是在难以获取支气管活检样本进行组织学检查的情况下。