Li Jian-jun, Xu Liang, Zhang Rong-xiu, Sun Xiu-ying, Yang Hua, Zou Yang, Zhao Jia-liang
Beijing Institute of Ophthalmology, Beijing Tongren Ophthalmic Center, Capital University of Medical Sciences, Beijing 100730, China.
Zhonghua Yan Ke Za Zhi. 2005 Mar;41(3):221-5.
To investigate the diagnosis value of the frequency doubling perimetry (FDP) screening program in the aged 40 or more natural population-based glaucoma screening.
In 3 natural villages of Daxing District and 4 northern metropolitan communities of Beijing, 4439 subjects aged 40 or over were screened for glaucoma from May to October in 2001. The screening protocol C-20-1 of the frequency doubling perimetry (FDP) was used in all subjects. For suspect glaucoma subjects, TOP threshold visual field testing with an Octopus perimeter, gonioscopy and stereo fundusgraphy were performed on different days. Detected Glaucoma patients were classified as mild (MD 5 dB or less), moderate (MD > 5 dB and < 10 dB) and advanced (MD 10 dB or more) degrees according to their Octopus test results. FDP parameters including test time, numbers of abnormal location, comtotalon score and score by quadrant were analyzed. Data from one eye of normal subjects and milder eye of optic nerve damage in glaucoma subjects were analyzed.
After excluding subjects whose fixation error or false positive error was > 0.33, data from 4330 subjects (97.54%) were analyzed. If abnormality of one location or more was used as a FDP cutoff, and subjects were divided into normal and glaucoma two groups (excluded other eye diseases in non-glaucoma subjects); the FDP had a sensitivity of 50.70% (72/142), a specificity of 90.58% (2260/2340), an area under the ROC curve (AUC) of 0.74, a positive predictive value (PV) of 47.71%, a negative predictive value of 96.95%, a positive likelihood ratio (LR) of 14.83 and a negative LR of 0.51. If excluded the eyes without glaucomatous optic nerve changes and visual field damage, the FDP had a sensitivity of 76.39%, an AUC of 0.87, a positive PV of 40.74%, a negative PV of 99.25%, a positive LR of 22.34 and a negative LR of 0.24. The sensitivity of detecting mild, moderate and advanced glaucoma was 54.17%, 76.00% and 100.00%, respectively. There was strong negative correlation between FDP quadrant score and quadrant mean sensitivity (MS) of Octopus perimetry in glaucoma patients (Spearman correlation, Rs = -0.732, -0.628, -0.639, -0.679, all P = 0.000).
The FDP screening protocol C-20-1 is a very rapid functional test for screening glaucoma in large natural populations aged 40 or more and is proven to be feasible. It has high specificity and good sensitivity for moderate and advanced glaucoma.
探讨频率加倍视野计(FDP)筛查程序在40岁及以上自然人群青光眼筛查中的诊断价值。
2001年5月至10月,在北京大兴区的3个自然村落和4个北部城区社区,对4439名40岁及以上的受试者进行青光眼筛查。所有受试者均采用频率加倍视野计(FDP)的C-20-1筛查方案。对于疑似青光眼受试者,在不同日期进行Octopus视野计的TOP阈值视野检查、前房角镜检查和立体眼底照相。根据Octopus检查结果,将确诊的青光眼患者分为轻度(平均缺损5 dB或更低)、中度(平均缺损>5 dB且<10 dB)和重度(平均缺损10 dB或更高)。分析FDP参数,包括检查时间、异常部位数量、comtotalon评分和象限评分。分析正常受试者一只眼和青光眼受试者视神经损伤较轻眼的数据。
排除固视误差或假阳性误差>0.33的受试者后,分析了4330名受试者(97.54%)的数据。若将一个或更多部位异常作为FDP截断值,将受试者分为正常和青光眼两组(非青光眼受试者排除其他眼病);FDP的敏感性为50.70%(72/142),特异性为90.58%(2260/2340),ROC曲线下面积(AUC)为0.74,阳性预测值(PV)为47.71%,阴性预测值为96.95%,阳性似然比(LR)为14.83,阴性LR为0.51。若排除无青光眼性视神经改变和视野损害的眼,FDP的敏感性为76.39%,AUC为0.87,阳性PV为40.74%,阴性PV为99.25%,阳性LR为22.34,阴性LR为0.24。检测轻度、中度和重度青光眼的敏感性分别为54.17%、76.00%和100.00%。青光眼患者中,FDP象限评分与Octopus视野计象限平均敏感度(MS)之间存在强负相关(Spearman相关性,Rs = -0.732、-0.628、-0.639、-0.679,P均=0.000)。
FDP筛查方案C-20-1是一种非常快速的功能性检查,用于在40岁及以上的大型自然人群中筛查青光眼,且已被证明是可行的。它对中度和重度青光眼具有高特异性和良好的敏感性。