Iwase Aiko, Tomidokoro Atsuo, Araie Makoto, Shirato Shiroaki, Shimizu Hiroyuki, Kitazawa Yoshiaki
Department of Ophthalmology, Tajimi Municipal Hospital, Tajimi, Japan.
Ophthalmology. 2007 Jan;114(1):27-32. doi: 10.1016/j.ophtha.2006.06.041. Epub 2006 Oct 27.
To evaluate the performance of frequency-doubling technology (FDT) perimetry in a population-based glaucoma prevalence survey.
Population-based cross-sectional study.
Participants older than 40 years randomly selected from the population of Tajimi City.
Each participant underwent screening ophthalmic examinations including a visual field test using FDT with the C-20-1 screening protocol. A diagnosis of glaucoma was determined by glaucoma specialists with another detailed visual field test using Humphrey Field Analyzer (HFA; Humphrey Instruments, San Leandro, CA) with the 30-2 Swedish interactive threshold algorithm standard protocol and stereoscopic disc photographs.
The ratios of reliable FDT results and the sensitivity and specificity for detecting glaucoma in a general population.
Of 5784 eyes of 2892 participants (age range, 40-92 years; refractive error, -23 to 11 diopters) in whom FDT was performed in both eyes, reliable results (< or =33% fixation loss and < or =33% false-positive errors) were obtained in 5707 eyes (98.7%), including 2871 right eyes (99.3%) and 2836 left eyes (98.1%) with a significant bilateral difference (P<0.001, chi-square test). The rate of reliable FDT results did not differ between men and women (P = 0.81) but decreased with age. In 5582 eyes with reliable FDT results, FDT showed 1 or more abnormal points in the visual field in 502 eyes (9.0%), including 388 (7.3%) of 5295 normal eyes, 19 (16.4%) of 116 eyes of glaucoma suspects, and 95 (55.6%) of 171 eyes with definite glaucoma. The sensitivity and specificity values for detecting definite glaucoma were 55.6% and 92.7%, respectively. The positive and negative predictive values were 18.9% and 98.5%, respectively. In further analyses stratified with the mean deviation (MD) of the HFA, the sensitivities were 32.1%, 48.4%, 73.7%, and 96.6% for detecting definite glaucoma with an MD of more than -2 dB, an MD of -2 dB or less and more than -5 dB, an MD of -5 dB or less and more than -8 dB, and an MD of -8 dB or less, respectively.
In a population-based glaucoma screening study, FDT perimetry with the C-20-1 screening protocol was reliably performed in more than 98% of participants. The sensitivity for detecting glaucomatous visual field damages, especially early damage, was not sufficiently high, whereas the specificity was high.
在一项基于人群的青光眼患病率调查中评估倍频技术(FDT)视野检查的性能。
基于人群的横断面研究。
从多治见市人群中随机选取的40岁以上参与者。
每位参与者接受眼科筛查检查,包括使用C-20-1筛查方案的FDT视野测试。青光眼专家通过使用Humphrey视野分析仪(HFA;Humphrey仪器公司,加利福尼亚州圣莱安德罗)的30-2瑞典交互式阈值算法标准方案和立体视盘照片进行的另一项详细视野测试来确定青光眼诊断。
可靠FDT结果的比例以及在普通人群中检测青光眼的敏感性和特异性。
在2892名参与者(年龄范围40 - 92岁;屈光不正-23至11屈光度)的5784只眼中进行了双眼FDT检查,5707只眼(98.7%)获得了可靠结果(固定丢失率≤33%且假阳性错误率≤33%),其中包括2871只右眼(99.3%)和2836只左眼(98.1%),存在显著的双侧差异(P<0.001,卡方检验)。可靠FDT结果的比例在男性和女性之间无差异(P = 0.81),但随年龄增长而降低。在5582只获得可靠FDT结果的眼中,FDT显示视野中有1个或更多异常点的有502只眼(9.0%),包括5295只正常眼中的388只(7.3%)、116只青光眼疑似眼中的19只(16.4%)以及171只确诊青光眼眼中的95只(55.6%)。检测确诊青光眼的敏感性和特异性值分别为55.6%和92.7%。阳性和阴性预测值分别为18.9%和98.5%。在根据HFA的平均偏差(MD)进行分层的进一步分析中,对于MD大于-2 dB、MD为-2 dB或更低且大于-5 dB、MD为-5 dB或更低且大于-8 dB以及MD为-8 dB或更低的情况,检测确诊青光眼的敏感性分别为32.1%、48.4%、73.7%和96.6%。
在一项基于人群的青光眼筛查研究中,采用C-20-1筛查方案的FDT视野检查在超过98%的参与者中可靠地进行。检测青光眼性视野损害,尤其是早期损害的敏感性不够高,而特异性较高。