Wong David T, Lai Kevin, Chung Frances F, Ho Ranee Y
*Department of Anesthesiology, †University of Toronto, Ontario, Canada; and ‡McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.
Anesth Analg. 2005 May;100(5):1439-1446. doi: 10.1213/01.ANE.0000148695.37190.34.
The purpose of this study was to determine the preferences of Canadian anesthesiologists in difficult intubation and cannot intubate-cannot ventilate (CICV) situations. Using a mailed survey, we asked anesthesiologists their preferences for and comfort level in using (a) alternative airway devices in a difficult intubation scenario and (b) infraglottic airway in a CICV scenario. Chi-square analysis and Student's t-test were used for categorical and continuous variables. Nine-hundred-seventy-one of 2066 surveys were returned. In the difficult intubation scenario, the preferred alternative airway devices were lighted stylet (45%), fiberoptic bronchoscope (26%), and intubating laryngeal mask airway (20%). Only 57% of respondents had encountered a CICV situation in real life. In the CICV scenario, preferred infraglottic airways were cricothyroidotomy by IV catheter (51%), percutaneous cricothyroidotomy (28%), and tracheostomy by surgeon (14%). Anesthesiologists had little experience and were uncomfortable with open surgical infraglottic airways. Anesthesiologists with experience using infraglottic airways on mannequins were more comfortable using them in patients (P < 0.001). In conclusion, in a difficult intubation scenario, the lighted stylet has emerged as the preferred alternative airway device. In a CICV scenario, respondents preferred cricothyroidotomy by IV catheter, followed by percutaneous cricothyroidotomy and tracheostomy by surgeon. Practice on mannequins was associated with improved comfort in using infraglottic airways in patients.
本研究的目的是确定加拿大麻醉医生在困难气道插管和无法插管-无法通气(CICV)情况下的偏好。我们通过邮寄调查问卷,询问麻醉医生在(a)困难气道插管场景中使用替代气道装置以及(b)CICV场景中使用声门下气道的偏好和舒适度。对分类变量和连续变量分别采用卡方分析和学生t检验。2066份调查问卷中,有971份被收回。在困难气道插管场景中,首选的替代气道装置是光棒(45%)、纤维支气管镜(26%)和插管型喉罩气道(20%)。只有57%的受访者在现实生活中遇到过CICV情况。在CICV场景中,首选的声门下气道是经静脉导管行环甲膜切开术(51%)、经皮环甲膜切开术(28%)和外科医生行气管切开术(14%)。麻醉医生对开放性手术声门下气道经验较少且操作不熟练。在人体模型上有使用声门下气道经验的麻醉医生在患者身上使用时更得心应手(P<0.001)。总之,在困难气道插管场景中,光棒已成为首选的替代气道装置。在CICV场景中,受访者首选经静脉导管行环甲膜切开术,其次是经皮环甲膜切开术和外科医生行气管切开术。在人体模型上的练习与在患者身上使用声门下气道时舒适度的提高相关。