Jablonski Kathleen A, Guagliardo Mark F
Department of Prevention and Community Health, The George Washington University School of Public Health and Health Services, Washington, DC, USA.
Popul Health Metr. 2005 May 4;3(1):4. doi: 10.1186/1478-7954-3-4.
The U.S. National Healthcare Disparities Report is a recent effort to measure and monitor racial and ethnic disparities in health and healthcare. The Report is a work in progress and includes few indicators specific to children. An indicator worthy of consideration is racial/ethnic differences in the rate of bad outcomes for pediatric acute appendicitis. Bad outcomes for this condition are indicative of poor access to healthcare, which is amenable to social and healthcare policy changes. METHODS: We analyzed the KID Inpatient Database, a nationally representative sample of pediatric hospitalization, to compare rates of appendicitis rupture between white, African American, Hispanic and Asian children. We ran weighted logistic regression models to obtain national estimates of relative odds of rupture rate for the four groups, adjusted for developmental, biological, socioeconomic, health services and hospital factors that might influence disease outcome. RESULTS: Rupture was a much more burdensome outcome than timely surgery and rupture avoidance. Rupture cases had 97% higher hospital charges and 175% longer hospital stays than non-rupture cases on average. These burdens disproportionately affected minority children, who had 24% - 38% higher odds of appendicitis rupture than white children, adjusting for age and gender. These differences were reduced, but remained significant after adjusting for other factors. CONCLUSION: The racial/ethnic disparities in pediatric appendicitis outcome are large and are preventable with timely diagnosis and surgery for all children. Furthermore, estimating this disparity using the KID survey is a relatively straightforward process. Therefore pediatric appendicitis rupture rate is a good candidate for inclusion in the National Healthcare Disparities Report. As with most other health and healthcare disparities, efforts to reduce disparities in income, wealth and access to care will most likely improve the odds of favorable outcome for this condition as well.
《美国国家医疗保健差异报告》是近期一项旨在衡量和监测健康及医疗保健领域种族和族裔差异的工作。该报告仍在完善中,针对儿童的指标较少。一个值得考虑的指标是小儿急性阑尾炎不良结局发生率的种族/族裔差异。这种疾病的不良结局表明医疗保健可及性差,而这可通过社会和医疗保健政策的改变加以改善。
我们分析了儿童住院患者数据库(一个具有全国代表性的儿科住院样本),以比较白人、非裔美国人、西班牙裔和亚裔儿童的阑尾炎破裂率。我们运行加权逻辑回归模型,以获得这四组破裂率相对比值的全国估计值,并对可能影响疾病结局的发育、生物学、社会经济、医疗服务和医院因素进行了调整。
与及时手术和避免破裂相比,破裂是一个负担大得多的结局。破裂病例的住院费用平均比未破裂病例高97%,住院时间长175%。这些负担对少数族裔儿童的影响尤为严重,在调整年龄和性别后,他们患阑尾炎破裂的几率比白人儿童高24% - 38%。在调整其他因素后,这些差异有所减小,但仍然显著。
小儿阑尾炎结局的种族/族裔差异很大,通过对所有儿童进行及时诊断和手术是可以预防的。此外,使用儿童调查来估计这种差异是一个相对简单的过程。因此,小儿阑尾炎破裂率是纳入《国家医疗保健差异报告》的一个很好的候选指标。与大多数其他健康和医疗保健差异一样,努力减少收入、财富和医疗服务可及性方面的差异很可能也会提高这种疾病获得良好结局的几率。