Narayanan Siva, Van Vleet John, Strunk Billy, Ross Robert N, Gray Mikel
Beverly Enterprises, Fort Smith, Ark, USA.
J Wound Ostomy Continence Nurs. 2005 May-Jun;32(3):163-70. doi: 10.1097/00152192-200505000-00004.
This study compared clinical outcomes and nursing labor costs associated with (a) balsam Peru, hydrogenated castor oil, and trypsin (BCT) ointment; (b) BCT + Other; and (c) Other treatments in 2014 wound episodes occurring in 861 patients (mean 2.34 wounds/patient). Treatment with BCT ointment or BCT + Other was associated with a higher healing rate (P < .05). No Stage 1 or 2 ulcer treated with BCT ointment progressed, compared with 13.8% treated with BCT + Other and 13.4% treated with Other. The reported mean duration of treatment and time to heal were shorter for ulcers treated with BCT ointment, but differences did not reach significance, possibly because of the variability in reported treatment times. Mean daily nursing labor costs were lower for treatment with BCT than Other ($50.8 vs $61.7, P < .05). These data suggest that treatment of Stage 1 or 2 ulcers with BCT may be associated with shorter treatment time and time to heal and a potential reduction in treatment-related nursing labor costs.
本研究比较了2014年861例患者(平均每位患者2.34处伤口)出现的伤口事件中,与以下治疗相关的临床结局和护理劳动力成本:(a) 秘鲁香脂、氢化蓖麻油和胰蛋白酶(BCT)软膏;(b) BCT + 其他;以及(c) 其他治疗。使用BCT软膏或BCT + 其他进行治疗的愈合率更高(P < .05)。与接受BCT + 其他治疗的13.8%以及接受其他治疗的13.4%相比,接受BCT软膏治疗的1期或2期溃疡均未进展。报告显示,接受BCT软膏治疗的溃疡的平均治疗持续时间和愈合时间较短,但差异未达到显著水平,这可能是由于报告的治疗时间存在差异。BCT治疗的平均每日护理劳动力成本低于其他治疗(50.8美元对61.7美元,P < .05)。这些数据表明,使用BCT治疗1期或2期溃疡可能与更短的治疗时间和愈合时间相关,并可能降低与治疗相关的护理劳动力成本。