Amoo G, Ogunlesi A O
Aro Neuropsychiatric Hospital, P.M.B 2003, Abeokuta, Nigeria.
Afr J Med Med Sci. 2005 Mar;34(1):15-23.
Fifty seven each ofhospitalised schizophrenic patients (fulfilled diagnostic criteria for research version of I.C.D. 10) and diabetic patients respectively, matched for age and sex, were followed up from admission to discharge (July 1997 - December 1997). B.P.R.S. was used to measure the severity of psychopathology at admission and discharge for the former, while the levels of blood glucose at admission and discharge were assessed for the latter. Also, interviewed during the study were 374 relatives comprising 102 and 272 relatives of schizophrenic and diabetic patients respectively. Weekly assessments of cost of treatment were done from admission to discharge using the proforma which took cognisance of aspects of direct and indirect costs for patients and relatives of both groups. Schizophrenic patients had a poorer employment record (P = 0.000), more diabetic patients were married (P = 0.000), relatives shouldered the financial burden of care of more schizophrenic patients (P = 0.000), more schizophrenic patients travelled over an average of 122 km to reach the hospital whereas diabetic patients travelled averagely 19.8 km (P = 0.000) and the mean duration of admission for schizophrenic patients was significantly longer (P = 0.000). The mean monthly income for diabetic patients was significantly higher than for schizophrenic patients (P = 0.000), and the mean direct cost for schizophrenia per admission 9882.00 Naira was significantly higher than that of diabetes mellitus 7892.00 Naira (P = 0.000). The mean indirect cost for schizophrenic patients per admission which is 3604.00 Naira did not differ significantly from that of diabetic patients of 1488.00 Naira (P = 0.288). The mean total cost of schizophrenia per admission--is 11,337.00 Naira and was significantly higher than for diabetes 8571.00 Naira (P = 0.000). However, the mean direct cost per week for diabetes mellitus 4494.00 Naira was significantly higher than for schizophrenia 1011.00 Naira (P = 0.00). The mean indirect cost for diabetes mellitus per week 406.00 Naira did not differ significantly from that ofschizophrenia 168.00 Naira (P = 0.602). The mean total cost of diabetes mellitus per week 4910.00 Naira was significantly higher than for schizophrenia 1235.00 Naira (P = 0.000). Cost of medication ranked highest in all items of cost for both the schizophrenic and diabetic cohorts. The implications of the findings on clinical practice in Nigeria and our current socio-economic scenario (especially with regard to schizophrenic patients and their families) are discussed. The need to reinforce the socio-economic support from government and the larger society for schizophrenic patients and their families is highlighted.
分别选取了57名住院精神分裂症患者(符合国际疾病分类第10版研究版的诊断标准)和57名糖尿病患者,根据年龄和性别进行匹配,从入院到出院(1997年7月至1997年12月)进行随访。前者采用简明精神病评定量表(BPRS)在入院和出院时测量精神病理学严重程度,后者则评估入院和出院时的血糖水平。此外,在研究期间对374名亲属进行了访谈,其中分别包括102名精神分裂症患者的亲属和272名糖尿病患者的亲属。从入院到出院,每周使用考虑了两组患者及其亲属直接和间接费用方面的表格对治疗费用进行评估。精神分裂症患者的就业记录较差(P = 0.000),更多糖尿病患者已婚(P = 0.000),亲属承担了更多精神分裂症患者的护理经济负担(P = 0.000),更多精神分裂症患者平均行程122公里前往医院,而糖尿病患者平均行程19.8公里(P = 0.000),精神分裂症患者的平均住院时间明显更长(P = 0.000)。糖尿病患者的平均月收入明显高于精神分裂症患者(P = 0.000),精神分裂症每次入院的平均直接费用9882.00奈拉明显高于糖尿病的7892.00奈拉(P = 0.000)。精神分裂症患者每次入院的平均间接费用3604.00奈拉与糖尿病患者的1488.00奈拉相比无显著差异(P = 0.288)。精神分裂症每次入院的平均总费用为11337.00奈拉,明显高于糖尿病的8571.00奈拉(P = 0.000)。然而,糖尿病每周的平均直接费用4494.00奈拉明显高于精神分裂症的1011.00奈拉(P = 0.00)。糖尿病每周的平均间接费用406.00奈拉与精神分裂症的168.00奈拉相比无显著差异(P = 0.602)。糖尿病每周的平均总费用4910.00奈拉明显高于精神分裂症的1235.00奈拉(P = 0.000)。在精神分裂症和糖尿病患者群体的所有费用项目中,药物费用排名最高。讨论了这些研究结果对尼日利亚临床实践以及我们当前社会经济状况(特别是关于精神分裂症患者及其家庭)的影响。强调了政府和更广泛社会加强对精神分裂症患者及其家庭社会经济支持的必要性。