Davison James A
Ophthalmology and Visual Sciences, University of Utah, Salt Lake City, Utah, USA.
J Cataract Refract Surg. 2005 May;31(5):1015-9. doi: 10.1016/j.jcrs.2004.09.025.
To compare the phacoemulsification times and powers used in 3 phacoemulsification machine configurations.
Wolfe Eye Clinic, Marshalltown, Iowa, USA.
A randomized prospective study of 410 consecutive cases was conducted. All cases were performed using the Alcon Legacy 20000 phacoemulsification machine. Configurations were the Standard Legacy 20000 machine (n=165), Advantec upgraded Legacy 20000 (n=112), and Advantec upgraded Legacy 20000 with NeoSoniX (n=133). Preoperative measurements included the patient's age and cataract grade using the nuclear color (NC) scale of the Lens Opacities Classification System III (LOCS III). Intraoperative measurements included machine-measured phacoemulsification time and average percentage of maximum power expenditure. An independent statistician performed analysis of covariance on NC for each of the machine configurations.
The mean age in years and the NC value were similar in each group. There was no significant difference in phacoemulsification time in minutes among the 3 machines: Standard=1.17, Advantec=1.12, NeoSoniX=1.16. The average percentage of maximum power consumption was similar for Standard Legacy 20000 at 38.00% and Advantec Legacy 20000 at 37.97% but significantly less for Advantec Legacy 20000 with NeoSoniX at 27.56% (P<.001). With the NeoSoniX-incorporated machine, compared with Standard and Advantec, a 27.5% reduction in ultrasonic energy power expenditure was observed all grades of nuclear density.
The addition of 15% amplitude NeoSoniX rotational energy reduced total ultrasonic power expenditure by 27.5% for all cataract nuclear densities.
比较三种超声乳化机器配置下的超声乳化时间及使用功率。
美国爱荷华州马歇尔敦市沃尔夫眼科诊所。
对410例连续病例进行随机前瞻性研究。所有病例均使用爱尔康Legacy 20000超声乳化机器。配置分别为标准Legacy 20000机器(n = 165)、Advantec升级后的Legacy 20000(n = 112)以及配备NeoSoniX的Advantec升级后的Legacy 20000(n = 133)。术前测量包括患者年龄以及使用晶状体混浊分类系统III(LOCS III)的核颜色(NC)量表评估的白内障分级。术中测量包括机器测量的超声乳化时间以及最大功率消耗的平均百分比。一名独立统计学家对每种机器配置的NC进行协方差分析。
每组的平均年龄(岁)和NC值相似。三种机器的超声乳化时间(分钟)无显著差异:标准型 = 1.17,Advantec型 = 1.12,NeoSoniX型 = 1.16。标准Legacy 20000的最大功率消耗平均百分比为38.00%,Advantec Legacy 20000为37.97%,二者相似,但配备NeoSoniX的Advantec Legacy 20000显著更低,为27.56%(P <.001)。对于配备NeoSoniX的机器,与标准型和Advantec型相比,在所有核密度等级中,超声能量功率消耗均降低了27.5%。
对于所有白内障核密度,添加15%振幅的NeoSoniX旋转能量可使总超声功率消耗降低27.5%。