Nogi Taisaku, Yuan Yan Emily, Sorocco Debra, Perez-Tomas Ricardo, Levin Michael
Cytokine Biology Department, The Forsyth Institute, and Department of Oral and Developmental Biology, Harvard School of Dental Medicine, Boston, MA 02115, USA.
Laterality. 2005 May;10(3):193-205. doi: 10.1080/1357650054200001440.
Consistent visceral asymmetry in vertebrates raises fascinating questions about the developmental mechanisms and evolutionary origin of fixed chirality of the left-right axis. One persistent controversy is whether consistently biased asymmetry is a later innovation imposed on a bilaterally symmetrical primitive body-plan, or whether asymmetry is a fundamental property predating the bilateria. The morphology of planaria suggests proximity to the origin of the bilateral body-plan, and they are commonly thought to be left-right symmetrical, as no consistent anatomical asymmetries have been described despite over a century of study of regeneration. Here, we show that D. japonica possess a consistent functional asymmetry in eye patterning defects caused by inhibition of H+/K+-ATPase activity (an ion flux mechanism recently shown to be an important early step in the asymmetry of several vertebrate embryos). Moreover, an endogenous transcript of the non-gastric H+/K+-ATPase subunit alpha is expressed in the head blastema shortly after amputation. Taken together, these data suggest that (1) left-right asymmetry is at least as old as planaria, (2) subtle functional asymmetries should be sought in other more primitive model systems that are believed to be symmetrical, and (3) symmetrical paired structures may in fact contain information about their position on the L or R side.
脊椎动物中一致的内脏不对称现象引发了关于左右轴固定手性的发育机制和进化起源的有趣问题。一个长期存在的争议是,持续偏向的不对称是后来施加于双侧对称原始身体结构上的创新,还是不对称是早于两侧对称动物出现的基本属性。涡虫的形态表明其接近双侧身体结构的起源,并且通常认为它们是左右对称的,因为尽管经过了一个多世纪的再生研究,仍未发现一致的解剖学不对称现象。在此,我们表明日本三角涡虫在因抑制H⁺/K⁺-ATP酶活性(一种离子通量机制,最近被证明是几种脊椎动物胚胎不对称发育的重要早期步骤)而导致的眼模式缺陷中存在一致的功能不对称。此外,非胃H⁺/K⁺-ATP酶亚基α的内源性转录本在截肢后不久就在头部再生芽基中表达。综合这些数据表明:(1)左右不对称至少与涡虫一样古老;(2)应该在其他被认为是对称的更原始模型系统中寻找细微的功能不对称;(3)对称的成对结构实际上可能包含有关其在左侧或右侧位置的信息。