Dahl Tove I, Bals Margrethe, Turi Anne Lene
Department of Psychology, University of Tromsø, Norway.
Br J Educ Psychol. 2005 Jun;75(Pt 2):257-73. doi: 10.1348/000709905X25049.
Although considerable research has examined beliefs and learning outcomes (e.g. Schommer, 1990, 1993a, 1993b; Schommer & Dunnell, 1997), little has looked at the relationship between beliefs and the actual learning process.
This research examines the relationship between beliefs about learning and knowledge, and reports of learning strategy-use relevant for successful text comprehension.
Participants were 81 Norwegian university students who had studied from 1 to 4 years in a range of disciplines.
Students' beliefs about knowledge and learning were measured with the Schommer Epistemological Questionnaire (SEQ; Schommer, 1998b). Learning strategies particularly useful for text-based learning were measured with the Motivated Strategies for Learning Questionnaire (MSLQ; Pintrich, Smith, Garcia, & McKeachie, 1991). A correlational analysis between measures and full regression analyses of how beliefs influence strategy selection were performed.
Beliefs about how thoroughly knowledge is integrated in networks (simple) and how fixed the ability to learn is from birth (fixed) contributed significantly to reported strategy use: Simple to rehearsal and organizational strategies, fixed to elaboration and critical thinking strategies, and a combination of simple and fixed to strategies relevant to the thoughtful monitoring of learning tasks. Beliefs about how certain knowledge is (certain) and how quickly learning can be expected to occur (quick) were not found to contribute to reported learning- strategy use in any significant way.
Some, but not all, beliefs about knowledge and learning offer insight into students' reported use of learning strategies relevant for reading course literature.
尽管已有大量研究探讨了信念与学习成果(如舍默尔,1990年、1993年a、1993年b;舍默尔和邓内尔,1997年),但很少有研究关注信念与实际学习过程之间的关系。
本研究考察关于学习的信念与知识之间的关系,以及与成功的文本理解相关的学习策略使用报告。
参与者为81名挪威大学生,他们在一系列学科领域学习了1至4年。
使用舍默尔认识论问卷(SEQ;舍默尔,1998年b)测量学生对知识和学习的信念。使用学习动机策略问卷(MSLQ;平特里奇、史密斯、加西亚和麦基奇,1991年)测量对基于文本的学习特别有用的学习策略。对各项测量进行相关分析,并对信念如何影响策略选择进行完全回归分析。
关于知识在网络中整合的彻底程度(简单)以及学习能力从出生起就固定不变(固定)的信念,对报告的策略使用有显著贡献:简单信念与复述和组织策略相关,固定信念与精细加工和批判性思维策略相关,简单和固定信念的组合与对学习任务的深入监控相关的策略有关。关于知识的确定性(确定)以及预期学习发生的速度(快速)的信念,未被发现对报告的学习策略使用有任何显著贡献。
关于知识和学习的一些信念(但不是全部)有助于深入了解学生报告的与阅读课程文献相关的学习策略使用情况。