Samuelstuen Marit S, Bråten Ivar
Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Trondheim, Norway.
Scand J Psychol. 2005 Apr;46(2):107-17. doi: 10.1111/j.1467-9450.2005.00441.x.
We examined the relative contribution of decoding, topic knowledge, and strategic processing to the comprehension of social science text in a sample of Norwegian junior high school students. Additionally, we examined the interaction of topic knowledge with strategic processing on students' text comprehension, and whether poor word-level skill could be effectively compensated for by higher-level processing involving knowledge or strategies. Multiple regression analysis indicated that students' prior knowledge about the topic of the text contributed most to their comprehension. Students' reported use of organization and monitoring strategies contributed less but still significantly to text comprehension, as did their word decoding skills. However, no interaction between topic knowledge and strategic processing was found. Analyses of variance and post-hoc comparison tests, supplemented by a descriptive analysis, suggested that the coexistence of poor decoding skill and good text comprehension may be related to much topic knowledge, good strategy use, or both.
我们在一个挪威初中生样本中,研究了解码、主题知识和策略性加工对社会科学文本理解的相对贡献。此外,我们还研究了主题知识与策略性加工在学生文本理解上的相互作用,以及较差的单词层面技能是否能通过涉及知识或策略的高级加工得到有效补偿。多元回归分析表明,学生对文本主题的先验知识对其理解贡献最大。学生报告的组织和监控策略的使用贡献较小,但对文本理解仍有显著贡献,他们的单词解码技能也是如此。然而,未发现主题知识与策略性加工之间存在相互作用。方差分析和事后比较测试,辅以描述性分析,表明解码技能差与良好的文本理解并存可能与丰富的主题知识、良好的策略运用或两者都有关。