Wilson Thomas A, Nicolosi Robert J, Kotyla Timothy, Sundram Kalyana, Kritchevsky David
Department of Health and Clinical Sciences, Center for Health and Disease Research, University of Massachusetts Lowell, Lowell, MA 01854-5125, USA.
J Nutr Biochem. 2005 Oct;16(10):633-40. doi: 10.1016/j.jnutbio.2005.03.007.
Several studies have reported on the effect of refined, bleached and deodorized palm oil (RBD-PO) incorporation into the diet on blood cholesterol concentrations and on the development of atherosclerosis. However, very little work has been reported on the influence of red palm oil (RPO), which is higher in carotenoid and tocopherol content than RBD-PO. Thus, we studied the influence of RPO, RBD-PO and a RBD-PO plus red palm oil extract (reconstituted RBD-PO) on plasma cholesterol concentrations and aortic accumulation vs. hamsters fed coconut oil. Forty-eight F1B Golden Syrian hamsters (Mesocricetus auratus) (BioBreeders, Watertown, MA) were group housed (three/cage) in hanging polystyrene cages with bedding in an air-conditioned facility maintained on a 12-h light/dark cycle. The hamsters were fed a chow-based hypercholesterolemic diet (HCD) containing 10% coconut oil and 0.1% cholesterol for 2 weeks at which time they were bled after an overnight fast and segregated into four groups of 12 with similar plasma cholesterol concentrations. Group 1 continued on the HCD, Group 2 was fed the HCD containing 10% RPO in place of coconut oil, Group 3 was fed the HCD containing 10% RBD-PO in place of coconut oil and Group 4 was fed the HCD with 10% reconstituted RBD-PO for an additional 10 weeks. Plasma total cholesterol (TC) and non-high-density lipoprotein-cholesterol (HDL-C) (very low- and low-density lipoprotein) concentrations were significantly lower in the hamsters fed the RPO (-42% and -48%), RBD-PO (-32% and -36%) and the reconstituted RBD-PO (-37% and -41%) compared to the coconut oil-fed hamsters. Plasma HDL-C concentrations were significantly higher by 14% and 31% in hamsters fed the RBD-PO and RPO compared to the coconut oil-fed hamsters. Plasma triglyceride (TG) concentrations were significantly lower in hamsters fed RBD-PO (-32%) and the reconstituted RBD-PO (-31%) compared to the coconut oil-fed hamsters. The plasma gamma-tocopherol concentrations were higher in the coconut oil-fed hamsters compared to the hamsters fed the RPO (60%), RBD-PO (42%) and the reconstituted RBD-PO (49%), while for plasma alpha-tocopherol concentrations, the coconut oil-fed hamsters were significantly higher than only the RPO-fed hamsters (21%). The coconut oil-fed hamsters also had significantly higher plasma lipid hydroperoxide concentrations compared to RBD-PO (112%) and the reconstituted RBD-PO (485%). The hamsters fed the coconut oil diet excreted significantly more fecal total neutral sterols and cholesterol compared to the hamsters fed the RBD-PO (158% and 167%, respectively). The coconut oil-fed hamsters had significantly higher levels of aortic total, free and esterified cholesterol compared to the hamsters fed the RPO (74%, 50% and 225%, respectively), RBD-PO (57%, 48% and 92%, respectively) and the reconstituted RBD-PO (111%, 94% and 94%, respectively). Also, aortic free/ester cholesterol ratio in the aortas of hamsters fed RPO was significantly higher than in those fed the coconut oil (124%). In conclusion, hamsters fed the three palm oil preparations had lower plasma TC and non-HDL-C and higher HDL-C concentrations while accumulating less aortic cholesterol concentrations compared to hamsters fed coconut oil.
多项研究报告了将精炼、漂白和除臭棕榈油(RBD-PO)添加到饮食中对血液胆固醇浓度和动脉粥样硬化发展的影响。然而,关于红棕榈油(RPO)的影响的报道却很少,红棕榈油的类胡萝卜素和生育酚含量比RBD-PO高。因此,我们研究了RPO、RBD-PO以及RBD-PO加红棕榈油提取物(重构RBD-PO)对血浆胆固醇浓度和主动脉胆固醇积累的影响,并与喂食椰子油的仓鼠进行了对比。48只F1B金黄叙利亚仓鼠(Mesocricetus auratus)(BioBreeders公司,马萨诸塞州沃特敦)被分组饲养(三只/笼)在悬挂式聚苯乙烯笼子里,笼子里有垫料,饲养在一个维持12小时光照/黑暗周期的空调设施中。仓鼠先喂食含10%椰子油和0.1%胆固醇的高胆固醇饮食(HCD)2周,此时它们在禁食过夜后采血,并根据血浆胆固醇浓度相似的原则分为四组,每组12只。第1组继续喂食HCD,第2组喂食含10%RPO替代椰子油的HCD,第3组喂食含10%RBD-PO替代椰子油的HCD,第4组喂食含10%重构RBD-PO的HCD,持续10周。与喂食椰子油的仓鼠相比,喂食RPO(分别降低42%和48%)、RBD-PO(分别降低32%和36%)和重构RBD-PO(分别降低37%和41%)的仓鼠血浆总胆固醇(TC)和非高密度脂蛋白胆固醇(HDL-C)(极低密度脂蛋白和低密度脂蛋白)浓度显著降低。与喂食椰子油的仓鼠相比,喂食RBD-PO和RPO的仓鼠血浆HDL-C浓度分别显著升高14%和31%。与喂食椰子油的仓鼠相比,喂食RBD-PO(降低32%)和重构RBD-PO(降低31%)的仓鼠血浆甘油三酯(TG)浓度显著降低。与喂食RPO(降低60%)、RBD-PO(降低42%)和重构RBD-PO(降低49%)的仓鼠相比,喂食椰子油的仓鼠血浆γ-生育酚浓度更高,而对于血浆α-生育酚浓度,喂食椰子油的仓鼠仅显著高于喂食RPO的仓鼠(高21%)。与RBD-PO(高112%)和重构RBD-PO(高485%)相比,喂食椰子油的仓鼠血浆脂质氢过氧化物浓度也显著更高。与喂食RBD-PO的仓鼠相比,喂食椰子油饮食的仓鼠粪便中总中性固醇和胆固醇排泄量显著更多(分别高158%和167%)。与喂食RPO(分别高74%、50%和225%)、RBD-PO(分别高57%、48%和92%)和重构RBD-PO(分别高111%、94%和94%)的仓鼠相比,喂食椰子油的仓鼠主动脉中总胆固醇、游离胆固醇和酯化胆固醇水平显著更高。此外,喂食RPO的仓鼠主动脉中游离/酯化胆固醇比值显著高于喂食椰子油的仓鼠(高124%)。总之,与喂食椰子油的仓鼠相比,喂食三种棕榈油制剂的仓鼠血浆TC和非HDL-C更低,HDL-C更高,同时主动脉胆固醇积累更少。